Because he's vanilla today and the SK shot Axelrod.
Because if he was SK he'd totally be telling the truth about being vanilla. And shooting Axelrod doesn't make a whole lot of sense no matter who the SK is. Neither of these things takes RafK out of the SK pool. I also can't remember why Axel was taken out of the pool.
Also, it's terribly unlikely that I'm mafia assuming I'm telling the truth about my role (which we can easily be tested). The reasoning there goes that on night 3, 3 presumably scum actions are missing (the cake, the kill, and the flowers) and yet Dagger managed to target me.
Someone else targeted you that night? Are you notified if your ability triggered?
I wasn't, so apparently not.
Quote from Azrael »
14. Puzzle (replacing Charmmaster3125, replacing Sorryguy {who was replaced by Chamber [who has been replaced by Niv]}, replacing Sutherlands, replacing H_C, replacing MJM, replacing Sutherlands)
If Charmmaster has his own role on the replacement list, I think it's safe to say that, uh, 'Niv' does too.
Quote from ZDS »
Spoon, feel free to name claim any time you want.
I'll get on that when AG steps up to the same request.
What did he mean, this role is a "tree" that has been cut down?
\
He was referring to Grak's 'tree theory' explained on day 1.
I'm whatever to a mass claim. I'll go along with one, but I think we've got enough targets not to need one. Hawkeye and RafK both seem like better places to me.
Knowing his existence, I say Dagger and his ability to let an arbitrarily large amount of players into his communication group without revealing them anything important just does not fit.
How doesn't it fit? It's obviously the real deal unless you're calling Dagger, Axel, Cyan, Me, and anyone I'm forgetting all liars. Two communication roles like this don't seem out of the question, and it looks like Charm can only use his while in the game. What's the problem?
I kinda like it.
Yes, it is.
No can do.
Can't do that, either.
That one I can manage. I'm Morpheus.
Because if he was SK he'd totally be telling the truth about being vanilla. And shooting Axelrod doesn't make a whole lot of sense no matter who the SK is. Neither of these things takes RafK out of the SK pool. I also can't remember why Axel was taken out of the pool.
Also, it's terribly unlikely that I'm mafia assuming I'm telling the truth about my role (which we can easily be tested). The reasoning there goes that on night 3, 3 presumably scum actions are missing (the cake, the kill, and the flowers) and yet Dagger managed to target me.
I'll claim whatever the rest I should soon.
I wasn't, so apparently not.
If Charmmaster has his own role on the replacement list, I think it's safe to say that, uh, 'Niv' does too.
I'll get on that when AG steps up to the same request.
Which makes me a little curious about Dagger successfully targeting me.
Hawkeye only had 1 vote on him in that last votecount, but ZDS and Cyan were both voting him. Just to make sure, is this a mistake?
Vote HAWKEYE7. I'm willing to roll with this.
He was referring to Grak's 'tree theory' explained on day 1.
I'm whatever to a mass claim. I'll go along with one, but I think we've got enough targets not to need one. Hawkeye and RafK both seem like better places to me.
How doesn't it fit? It's obviously the real deal unless you're calling Dagger, Axel, Cyan, Me, and anyone I'm forgetting all liars. Two communication roles like this don't seem out of the question, and it looks like Charm can only use his while in the game. What's the problem?