Good heavens, I go away for a few hours and Burning Earth burns down in spectacular fashion. I have every intent of supporting your lynch, BE, but I am going to unvote because you're at L-1, haven't claimed, nor has everyone checked in.
Why do you think Kosa is town? Who do you think is scum and why, specifically?
Whoa I was at l-1 ! Jeez guys.
Void is scum for his horrible behaviour around voting me. He votes a naked vote then explains it with reasons he didn't have before his vote and only after I have drawn scrutiny.
I am an apprentice with the cult of Al-Naxis. I have been there a few years. I am apprenticed To a high ranking master who is researching stars. I had friends in the cult who left. However, there is a new apprentice who I am friends with. Unfortunately, there is also a snobbish new person who annoys me.
My neighbours and I have already established that our flavour doesn't reference each other
Mafia 101, BE. There is no reason to react, at all, to one vote on you. The fact that you did makes my vote look that much better. Also, you are trying to discredit me by claiming my vote is "bad".
I found one Scum here.
Nope your vote is fine. RVS. Well was until this post in which you reversed the RVS ness and misrepresented me. I said your vote would be bad IF it wasn't RVS
And let me restate, I wouldn't be reacting to your vote if it wasn't based on a complete misrepresentation!
Hey B_E, what is void misrepresenting here with his vote?
Recap: it seems that B_E is self destructing, the neighbor claim i don't think can be proved either way. (I would rather not want it verified currently either).
I would rather not lynch B_E soon, as of now the thread is mostly B_E and everyone else going against B_E (for Good reason). I think that we need a bit more information.
EVERYONE ELSE: Have you played any games with B_E? Is this the way he usually reacts to pressure?
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Looking for competitive discussion? Come Join Diestoremoval.com!
Mafia 101, BE. There is no reason to react, at all, to one vote on you. The fact that you did makes my vote look that much better. Also, you are trying to discredit me by claiming my vote is "bad".
I found one Scum here.
Nope your vote is fine. RVS. Well was until this post in which you reversed the RVS ness and misrepresented me. I said your vote would be bad IF it wasn't RVS
And let me restate, I wouldn't be reacting to your vote if it wasn't based on a complete misrepresentation!
Hey B_E, what is void misrepresenting here with his vote?
Recap: it seems that B_E is self destructing, the neighbor claim i don't think can be proved either way. (I would rather not want it verified currently either).
I would rather not lynch B_E soon, as of now the thread is mostly B_E and everyone else going against B_E (for Good reason). I think that we need a bit more information.
EVERYONE ELSE: Have you played any games with B_E? Is this the way he usually reacts to pressure?
A: He said I said his vote was bad. I only said it was bad IF it was serious. However it was so his vote was bad, so as it stands nothing.
I don't have any hard numbers on this, but I'm targeted more often than a black guy driving a beat-up sedan with a broken tail-light and no license plate, and Cy's well aware of that.
This wagon is really fast and seems opportunistic. I have some experience playing with BE that I cannot reference but he was just run up to L-1 with an RVS vote still on him. No one else finds this questionable?
Despite his self-consciousness, I find it more likely that there are scum pushing his wagon than that he's actually scum.
Rezombied started with a naked vote on Meggido. If it was an RVS vote, it was late in the game as plenty was already happening, and it didn't include anything to make it seem an RVS vote like a joke, etc.
If it was a serious vote to pressure Meggido, then I would have expected much more of a follow up or pressure in his following post. Instead, when Meggido called him on it, he immediately shifted his focus onto BE's wagon while making a passing comment to Meggido about being touchy.
So, either Rezombied felt the need to RVS vote well after it was over and to do so by naked voting, or he placed a serious vote and then almost immediately changed his focus to the wagon that was already well established when he placed his first vote.
Then, his vote of BE was justified by one-liners basically reiterating other points that had already been made, and his vote put BE to L-1 with an RVS vote on the wagon and with several players not having checked back in from RVS or even posted at all.
I'm also suspicious of Odd iGem as his initial reasoning for pushing BE based on reformatting his vote seems like a reach to me. He seems to test the waters in a non-commital way until Void pushes the case with a vote. After that, he adds his vote and his tone gets much more assertive. There's also buddying with Void after Void took up the case. I think that Odd iGem was poking at low-hanging fruit and waiting to see if anyone would pick up his momentum before running with it himself. He's my other top suspect after Rezombied right now.
My strongest Town read thus far is Void - his play is very similar to the beginning of Futurama even down to the verbiage he used when clarifying that he likes his vote on BE more, which is what he said about his vote on iRebel at the beginning of that game. He's playing more freely than in his scum games I've played with him.
I don't have a good handle on Meggido or Kosa yet but their votes seemed authentic to me. Neither immediately jumped on the wagon until #82 happened, which was bad, and both voted as soon as they saw it in what appeared to be reaction votes.
If it was a serious vote to pressure Meggido, then I would have expected much more of a follow up or pressure in his following post. Instead, when Meggido called him on it, he immediately shifted his focus onto BE's wagon while making a passing comment to Meggido about being touchy.
So, either Rezombied felt the need to RVS vote well after it was over and to do so by naked voting, or he placed a serious vote and then almost immediately changed his focus to the wagon that was already well established when he placed his first vote.
Then, his vote of BE was justified by one-liners basically reiterating other points that had already been made, and his vote put BE to L-1 with an RVS vote on the wagon and with several players not having checked back in from RVS or even posted at all.
I voted meg and then started my read through.
I wasn't aware that my vote put B_E at L-1, and I don't really care, I think he's scum.
So, how is what I did scummy exactly?
~Mod note: I'm experimenting a bit with the votecount format. If it gets too obnoxious or there's some iota of information that you want that I'm not providing, let me know and I'll work it in. Need to find a style that works for me, after all
The numbers in () after a vote are the post number in which that vote appears.
I would vote Burning Earth right now if he wasn't at L-2. He is oozing self-consciousness and spamming the thread. Also, if he's scum, TubeHunter is likely his teammate due to [REDACTED] and 103. He wants to slow down because we need more information, but gives himself an out by saying that everyone is piling on BE "for good reason".
I would vote Burning Earth right now if he wasn't at L-2. He is oozing self-consciousness and spamming the thread. Also, if he's scum, TubeHunter is likely his teammate due to [REDACTED] and 103. He wants to slow down because we need more information, but gives himself an out by saying that everyone is piling on BE "for good reason".
I do want us to slow down. I would rather not go into day two if B_E is town and we quicklynched him in 2 days with a bunch of one liners.
I don't know how I'm giving myself "an out". Do you not think that BE is getting votes for good reason?
B_E, seeing as you are L2, do you have any town-scum reads that you would like to share with us?
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Looking for competitive discussion? Come Join Diestoremoval.com!
I am an apprentice with the cult of Al-Naxis. I have been there a few years. I am apprenticed To a high ranking master who is researching stars. I had friends in the cult who left. However, there is a new apprentice who I am friends with. Unfortunately, there is also a snobbish new person who annoys me.
My neighbours and I have already established that our flavour doesn't reference each other
hello this is important
You are suggesting that you have two partners with whom you can communicate. Is this true? When are you able to communicate? What information do you know about them? (don't tell us the specific info, just what info, i.e., "I know the names and alignments of two people," but don't actually tell us who).
Do not out your partners; and the same goes for your partners (should they exist)—do not out yourselves.
Do you have any other abilities?
What is "brand"?
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Can we have Megiddo removed from the forum forever please?
i'm pretty sure i can find your ***** online within 3 minutes
I am an apprentice with the cult of Al-Naxis.1 I have been there a few years. I am apprenticed To a high ranking master who is researching stars. I had friends in the cult who left. However, there is a new apprentice who I am friends with. Unfortunately, there is also a snobbish new person who annoys me.
My neighbours and I have already established that our flavour doesn't reference each other
Claims "neighbour", but has "Cult" in his flavor?
Since you're an "apprentice", BE, then you should be able to tell us who the leader of your Cult is.
This claim is fake. That "townie" over there instead of Town is a subtle scumtell because it denotes BE couldn't copypaste his role name and alignment and post it straight away. He's scum.
It's pretty much the same as scum!LnG falseclaiming "Town VT" in Battlestar Galactica. Lynch it.
I voted meg and then started my read through.
I wasn't aware that my vote put B_E at L-1, and I don't really care, I think he's scum.
So, how is what I did scummy exactly?
What was the purpose of your vote on Meg?
As soon as you were called on it you shifted your focus to the BE wagon. And your justification was a series of one liners that offered no additional content and basically just barned what other players were saying... so why rush a vote in there if you're not offering anything new and when several other players haven't checked in with real content?
Putting BE at L-1 allows a quick hammer which would have ended the day. I don't buy that you didn't know that your vote at least put him within claim range.
Hey guys. I want to let you know that i am here. But on my phone. Unfortunately i have been working the past 2 days and havent had much time to read. I will try to get a read done when i get home. Sorry for the delay.
Join Planar Chaos, A Colo clan
Generation B1: The first time you see this, copy and paste it into your sig and add 1 to the generation. social experiment.
If it was a serious vote to pressure Meggido, then I would have expected much more of a follow up or pressure in his following post. Instead, when Meggido called him on it, he immediately shifted his focus onto BE's wagon while making a passing comment to Meggido about being touchy.
So, either Rezombied felt the need to RVS vote well after it was over and to do so by naked voting, or he placed a serious vote and then almost immediately changed his focus to the wagon that was already well established when he placed his first vote.
Then, his vote of BE was justified by one-liners basically reiterating other points that had already been made, and his vote put BE to L-1 with an RVS vote on the wagon and with several players not having checked back in from RVS or even posted at all.
I voted meg and then started my read through.
I wasn't aware that my vote put B_E at L-1, and I don't really care, I think he's scum.
So, how is what I did scummy exactly?
Hey Rez, you missed my questions. Answer them please.
Also, you don't care that you put someone at L-1 without a claim less than a hundred posts into the game? When several people hadn't checked in? Really? Even if BE is scum there's no reason to put us in a situation where someone could either accidentally hammer or a scum buddy could quick hammer and deny us our number one tool: the Day.
If there's a pro-town aspect to your logic, I'm not seeing it.
This claim is fake. That "townie" over there instead of Town is a subtle scumtell because it denotes BE couldn't copypaste his role name and alignment and post it straight away. He's scum.
It's pretty much the same as scum!LnG falseclaiming "Town VT" in Battlestar Galactica. Lynch it.
I don't have any hard numbers on this, but I'm targeted more often than a black guy driving a beat-up sedan with a broken tail-light and no license plate, and Cy's well aware of that.
I don't have any hard numbers on this, but I'm targeted more often than a black guy driving a beat-up sedan with a broken tail-light and no license plate, and Cy's well aware of that.
@DCIII:
You mentioned that you believe that Scum are pushing the BE wagon, but then label your Scum reads as Zed (who did not push BE until later) and Odd iGem, who didn't start the wagon either, but "tested the waters" as you put it.
Looking back at the postings from Odd iGem and can safely say that he did not push the wagon nearly as much as others.
So, I ask you, DCIII, who is the Scum pushing the BE wagon through?
As soon as you were called on [the Megiddo vote] you shifted your focus to the BE wagon. I already said I voted and then started my read through.
And your justification was a series of one liners that offered no additional content and basically just barned what other players were saying... so why rush a vote in there if you're not offering anything new and when several other players haven't checked in with real content? So, for someone to be lynched Day1 there has to be 7 people with unique reasons for voting for the person?
Putting BE at L-1 allows a quick hammer which would have ended the day. I don't buy that you didn't know that your vote at least put him within claim range. I wasn't aware that I put him at L-1, but he's scum, so lynch it.
@kosakosa saying townie not town is not a tell, i didn't copy and pasre from my PM no, but it would be stupid to copy paste that then paraphrase the rest.
I am an apprentice with the cult of Al-Naxis. I have been there a few years. I am apprenticed To a high ranking master who is researching stars. I had friends in the cult who left. However, there is a new apprentice who I am friends with. Unfortunately, there is also a snobbish new person who annoys me.
My neighbours and I have already established that our flavour doesn't reference each other
hello this is important
You are suggesting that you have two partners with whom you can communicate. Is this true? When are you able to communicate? What information do you know about them? (don't tell us the specific info, just what info, i.e., "I know the names and alignments of two people," but don't actually tell us who).
Do not out your partners; and the same goes for your partners (should they exist)—do not out yourselves.
Do you have any other abilities?
What is "brand"?
1: Yes and i have no info about them
2: I can communicate with them at any time.
3 I have no other abilities
4: Brand is my last name, strangely uncapitalised by me.
Yeah, i just read some of futurama and this does seem like townvoid, so unvote
Just because meta is lining up to another game does not make me Town.
And there is the matter of the Cult that you mentioned in your flavor. I would like for you to answer my question about that rather than avoiding it. And, yes, I am using the word avoid here because you are very obviously reading the thread, but not answering my question. More so since you quoted the post from Megs that right before my question.
@DCIII:
You mentioned that you believe that Scum are pushing the BE wagon, but then label your Scum reads as Zed (who did not push BE until later) and Odd iGem, who didn't start the wagon either, but "tested the waters" as you put it.
Looking back at the postings from Odd iGem and can safely say that he did not push the wagon nearly as much as others.
So, I ask you, DCIII, who is the Scum pushing the BE wagon through?
Each subsequent vote pushes a wagon forward.
Rezombied placed a vote "for no reason at all" and then jumped on the wagon to put BE at L-1, ditching his no reason vote despite taking issue with the response, and by offering one line quips without adding additional content. This wasn't his style in Futurama, either - compare his #86 in that game with his post where he voted BE by contrast. He was more inquisitive then, his tone was softer, and he was trying to figure out the game. Here, in his opening post of content he just piggy-backed on the existing wagon with one-liners.
I get the feeling that Odd iGem was looking for a reason to push BE and did so after your vote/Meggido showed interest.
Meggido and Kosa both seemed to be convinced by #82 and both voted quickly to that. Also, both of them and you have followed up your pressure by scrutinizing the claim and continuing to push there/find new angles on your reads; which makes me think that you are genuine in your push and makes me feel better about my read on those votes.
Yeah, i just read some of futurama and this does seem like townvoid, so unvote
Just because meta is lining up to another game does not make me Town.
And there is the matter of the Cult that you mentioned in your flavor. I would like for you to answer my question about that rather than avoiding it. And, yes, I am using the word avoid here because you are very obviously reading the thread, but not answering my question. More so since you quoted the post from Megs that right before my question.
I have no flavour info about the cult's leader. Don't blame me fir the flavour I received in my role PM, it isn't my fault.
Wait, so B_E's role says Neighbour, but flavour says Cult?
And he has a leader, but no information about him, or the other members of the group?
If you can communicate with them, what is stopping you from asking who each person is?
How do you even communicate without knowing who's who? Is it not obvious?
Also, neighbours are not confirmed town, just saying.
unvote
Sorry guys but my computer is officially on the fritz and i dobt like the idea pf playing mafia from my phone. /replace please.
Again sorry to have to be replaced. Have fun.
Join Planar Chaos, A Colo clan
Generation B1: The first time you see this, copy and paste it into your sig and add 1 to the generation. social experiment.
I agree with almost all of DCIII's first content post and I think he's town. His thought process echos mine.
Burning_Earth is probably derping!townVI - first wagon on a newb means that the newb is probably town, and while he's imploding I don't think he's scum. (see Tavanio in Drury Lane, Sir Karn in Smalltown Swap). He's also OMGUSing, which I think is a newb!town tell more often than not.
He's also continuing to post; not melting down and ragequitting the thread (to avoid interacting with his scumbuddies).
The only game of the 10 or so that I checked that had naked votes in the Random Voting Stage. Two in fact! Both belonging to mafia.
"A vote that is demonstrably random carries no motivation to be read into, and is completely informationless. This is not the intent of the "random voting stage"." -MS Wiki
If you think that's scummy, rezombied, then why are you doing it? Was your view on random voting w/out reasoning changed?
Wait, so B_E's role says Neighbour, but flavour says Cult?
And he has a leader, but no information about him, or the other members of the group?
If you can communicate with them, what is stopping you from asking who each person is?
How do you even communicate without knowing who's who? Is it not obvious?
Also, neighbours are not confirmed town, just saying.
Why are you guys trying to fish more information out of Burning_Earth's claim?
Also, there's a mindset inconsistency here - Odd iGem stated "no more jokes" to Burning Earth, but Odd's been the one joking around most during RVS.
a) "No more jokes" was stated to Void, not Burning Earth
b) "No more jokes" was a joke - it seems like that should be obvious given the few posts after that one.
Wait, so B_E's role says Neighbour, but flavour says Cult?
And he has a leader, but no information about him, or the other members of the group?
If you can communicate with them, what is stopping you from asking who each person is?
How do you even communicate without knowing who's who? Is it not obvious?
Also, neighbours are not confirmed town, just saying.
I hadn't refreshed in ~15 minutes, so there are posts in between.
Ah, alright.
Quote from Odd iGem »
b) "No more jokes" was a joke - it seems like that should be obvious given the few posts after that one.
Really? I didn't interpret it as such.
More to the point, what are you doing? I've looked at your posts and 60% of them are fluff, with the other 40% of them pushing and prodding Burning Earth.
No reaction to his claim + my defense? No thoughts on the other players in the thread?
Why did you respond to my accusations about you immediately and not to DCIII's?
Whoa I was at l-1 ! Jeez guys.
Void is scum for his horrible behaviour around voting me. He votes a naked vote then explains it with reasons he didn't have before his vote and only after I have drawn scrutiny.
I am an apprentice with the cult of Al-Naxis. I have been there a few years. I am apprenticed To a high ranking master who is researching stars. I had friends in the cult who left. However, there is a new apprentice who I am friends with. Unfortunately, there is also a snobbish new person who annoys me.
My neighbours and I have already established that our flavour doesn't reference each other
Hey B_E, what is void misrepresenting here with his vote?
Recap: it seems that B_E is self destructing, the neighbor claim i don't think can be proved either way. (I would rather not want it verified currently either).
I would rather not lynch B_E soon, as of now the thread is mostly B_E and everyone else going against B_E (for Good reason). I think that we need a bit more information.
EVERYONE ELSE: Have you played any games with B_E? Is this the way he usually reacts to pressure?
Fires Of Salvation
Must Read Post for any new player!
A: He said I said his vote was bad. I only said it was bad IF it was serious. However it was so his vote was bad, so as it stands nothing.
B: I have no usable history at this time.
Your reasoning for Void being scum is just bad.
UUU Azami, Lady of Scrolls
RRR Diaochan, Artful Beauty
UR(U/R) Tibor, Lumia, & Melek (WIP)
Mafia Stats
B: I disagree (obviously)
Post 70 just reads like he is trying to point out a tell where none is there. It also seems really aggressive. I mean, come on
"So you "know" huh"
Burning_Earth takes a bow.
This wagon is really fast and seems opportunistic. I have some experience playing with BE that I cannot reference but he was just run up to L-1 with an RVS vote still on him. No one else finds this questionable?
Despite his self-consciousness, I find it more likely that there are scum pushing his wagon than that he's actually scum.
---------------------------------------------------------------------
Rezombied started with a naked vote on Meggido. If it was an RVS vote, it was late in the game as plenty was already happening, and it didn't include anything to make it seem an RVS vote like a joke, etc.
If it was a serious vote to pressure Meggido, then I would have expected much more of a follow up or pressure in his following post. Instead, when Meggido called him on it, he immediately shifted his focus onto BE's wagon while making a passing comment to Meggido about being touchy.
So, either Rezombied felt the need to RVS vote well after it was over and to do so by naked voting, or he placed a serious vote and then almost immediately changed his focus to the wagon that was already well established when he placed his first vote.
Then, his vote of BE was justified by one-liners basically reiterating other points that had already been made, and his vote put BE to L-1 with an RVS vote on the wagon and with several players not having checked back in from RVS or even posted at all.
Vote: Rezombied
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
I'm also suspicious of Odd iGem as his initial reasoning for pushing BE based on reformatting his vote seems like a reach to me. He seems to test the waters in a non-commital way until Void pushes the case with a vote. After that, he adds his vote and his tone gets much more assertive. There's also buddying with Void after Void took up the case. I think that Odd iGem was poking at low-hanging fruit and waiting to see if anyone would pick up his momentum before running with it himself. He's my other top suspect after Rezombied right now.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
My strongest Town read thus far is Void - his play is very similar to the beginning of Futurama even down to the verbiage he used when clarifying that he likes his vote on BE more, which is what he said about his vote on iRebel at the beginning of that game. He's playing more freely than in his scum games I've played with him.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
I don't have a good handle on Meggido or Kosa yet but their votes seemed authentic to me. Neither immediately jumped on the wagon until #82 happened, which was bad, and both voted as soon as they saw it in what appeared to be reaction votes.
Town Win % = 75%
Mafia Win % = 75%
Overall Win % = 75%
Completed Game Log
2014: Best Mafia Performance (Group)
2014: Most Improved Player
2014: Best Town Player
2014: Best Overall Player
I voted meg and then started my read through.
I wasn't aware that my vote put B_E at L-1, and I don't really care, I think he's scum.
So, how is what I did scummy exactly?
B_E Imploded and a flood of one line posts from everyone.
Yay DC!
All aboard the zombie train.
So what? Low hanging fruit?
Not Voting -- iRebel (100), Deathjoey (0)
With 12 players alive, it is 7 votes for a lynch.
~Mod note: I'm experimenting a bit with the votecount format. If it gets too obnoxious or there's some iota of information that you want that I'm not providing, let me know and I'll work it in. Need to find a style that works for me, after all
The numbers in () after a vote are the post number in which that vote appears.
I would vote Burning Earth right now if he wasn't at L-2. He is oozing self-consciousness and spamming the thread. Also, if he's scum, TubeHunter is likely his teammate due to [REDACTED] and 103. He wants to slow down because we need more information, but gives himself an out by saying that everyone is piling on BE "for good reason".
Compare D1 activity levels.
Agree with DCIII and Kosa about Void, and DC himself (GIP-related) is also in his town meta.
You say all aboard, but you don't vote for Rez yourself. Why?
I do want us to slow down. I would rather not go into day two if B_E is town and we quicklynched him in 2 days with a bunch of one liners.
I don't know how I'm giving myself "an out". Do you not think that BE is getting votes for good reason?
B_E, seeing as you are L2, do you have any town-scum reads that you would like to share with us?
Fires Of Salvation
Must Read Post for any new player!
You are suggesting that you have two partners with whom you can communicate. Is this true? When are you able to communicate? What information do you know about them? (don't tell us the specific info, just what info, i.e., "I know the names and alignments of two people," but don't actually tell us who).
Do not out your partners; and the same goes for your partners (should they exist)—do not out yourselves.
Do you have any other abilities?
What is "brand"?
Claims "neighbour", but has "Cult" in his flavor?
Since you're an "apprentice", BE, then you should be able to tell us who the leader of your Cult is.
This claim is fake. That "townie" over there instead of Town is a subtle scumtell because it denotes BE couldn't copypaste his role name and alignment and post it straight away. He's scum.
It's pretty much the same as scum!LnG falseclaiming "Town VT" in Battlestar Galactica. Lynch it.
What was the purpose of your vote on Meg?
As soon as you were called on it you shifted your focus to the BE wagon. And your justification was a series of one liners that offered no additional content and basically just barned what other players were saying... so why rush a vote in there if you're not offering anything new and when several other players haven't checked in with real content?
Putting BE at L-1 allows a quick hammer which would have ended the day. I don't buy that you didn't know that your vote at least put him within claim range.
The only difference I see is that he got heavy pressure earlier here.
Town Win % = 75%
Mafia Win % = 75%
Overall Win % = 75%
Completed Game Log
2014: Best Mafia Performance (Group)
2014: Most Improved Player
2014: Best Town Player
2014: Best Overall Player
Which Final Fantasy Character Are You?
Outbreak
Generation B1: The first time you see this, copy and paste it into your sig and add 1 to the generation. social experiment.
Hey Rez, you missed my questions. Answer them please.
Also, you don't care that you put someone at L-1 without a claim less than a hundred posts into the game? When several people hadn't checked in? Really? Even if BE is scum there's no reason to put us in a situation where someone could either accidentally hammer or a scum buddy could quick hammer and deny us our number one tool: the Day.
If there's a pro-town aspect to your logic, I'm not seeing it.
If you're on board with lynching Rez, why aren't you voting for him?
Good catch Kosa.
I'm still down to lynch BE.
Why didn't you, Meg?
UUU Azami, Lady of Scrolls
RRR Diaochan, Artful Beauty
UR(U/R) Tibor, Lumia, & Melek (WIP)
Mafia Stats
@iRebel: Why did you repeat my question to Deathjoey?
Because I had typed it up before reading your post, and didn't see a reason to not ask it.
UUU Azami, Lady of Scrolls
RRR Diaochan, Artful Beauty
UR(U/R) Tibor, Lumia, & Melek (WIP)
Mafia Stats
You mentioned that you believe that Scum are pushing the BE wagon, but then label your Scum reads as Zed (who did not push BE until later) and Odd iGem, who didn't start the wagon either, but "tested the waters" as you put it.
Looking back at the postings from Odd iGem and can safely say that he did not push the wagon nearly as much as others.
So, I ask you, DCIII, who is the Scum pushing the BE wagon through?
I see scum, I want to lynch it.
Sorry I missed this. I voted him for no reason at all. His reaction was not was I was expecting.
Did I stutter?
1: Yes and i have no info about them
2: I can communicate with them at any time.
3 I have no other abilities
4: Brand is my last name, strangely uncapitalised by me.
Just because meta is lining up to another game does not make me Town.
And there is the matter of the Cult that you mentioned in your flavor. I would like for you to answer my question about that rather than avoiding it. And, yes, I am using the word avoid here because you are very obviously reading the thread, but not answering my question. More so since you quoted the post from Megs that right before my question.
Each subsequent vote pushes a wagon forward.
Rezombied placed a vote "for no reason at all" and then jumped on the wagon to put BE at L-1, ditching his no reason vote despite taking issue with the response, and by offering one line quips without adding additional content. This wasn't his style in Futurama, either - compare his #86 in that game with his post where he voted BE by contrast. He was more inquisitive then, his tone was softer, and he was trying to figure out the game. Here, in his opening post of content he just piggy-backed on the existing wagon with one-liners.
I get the feeling that Odd iGem was looking for a reason to push BE and did so after your vote/Meggido showed interest.
Meggido and Kosa both seemed to be convinced by #82 and both voted quickly to that. Also, both of them and you have followed up your pressure by scrutinizing the claim and continuing to push there/find new angles on your reads; which makes me think that you are genuine in your push and makes me feel better about my read on those votes.
What do you think about Rezombied's play?
Town Win % = 75%
Mafia Win % = 75%
Overall Win % = 75%
Completed Game Log
2014: Best Mafia Performance (Group)
2014: Most Improved Player
2014: Best Town Player
2014: Best Overall Player
Town Win % = 75%
Mafia Win % = 75%
Overall Win % = 75%
Completed Game Log
2014: Best Mafia Performance (Group)
2014: Most Improved Player
2014: Best Town Player
2014: Best Overall Player
I have no flavour info about the cult's leader. Don't blame me fir the flavour I received in my role PM, it isn't my fault.
you could just ask what their role names are, no?
What form of communication do you have with your group and are you allowed to quote from it?
Because I'm not sure if he's scum yet.
And he has a leader, but no information about him, or the other members of the group?
If you can communicate with them, what is stopping you from asking who each person is?
How do you even communicate without knowing who's who? Is it not obvious?
Also, neighbours are not confirmed town, just saying.
Sorry guys but my computer is officially on the fritz and i dobt like the idea pf playing mafia from my phone.
/replace please.
Again sorry to have to be replaced. Have fun.
Which Final Fantasy Character Are You?
Outbreak
Generation B1: The first time you see this, copy and paste it into your sig and add 1 to the generation. social experiment.
How many games have you been in with scum!KosaKosa?
Because I wanted to vote for Megiddo, and I wanted to RVS, and I wanted to try to get a reaction, which I did.
Prophylaxis
DCIII
Burning_Earth
iRebel
Tubehunter
DKingsland967
Kosakosa
Deathjoey
Megiddo
Void
rezombied
Odd_iGem
I agree with almost all of DCIII's first content post and I think he's town. His thought process echos mine.
Burning_Earth is probably derping!townVI - first wagon on a newb means that the newb is probably town, and while he's imploding I don't think he's scum. (see Tavanio in Drury Lane, Sir Karn in Smalltown Swap). He's also OMGUSing, which I think is a newb!town tell more often than not.
He's also continuing to post; not melting down and ragequitting the thread (to avoid interacting with his scumbuddies).
This pinged me when I was reading the thread pre-replacement - why do you care about how many days you can last?
Also, there's a mindset inconsistency here - Odd iGem stated "no more jokes" to Burning Earth, but Odd's been the one joking around most during RVS.
I mean, it can probably fit with "getting serious" later on after RVS, but it feels off to me.
rezombied's a little meta, but I've been following his home meta for a while and this feels strange to me:
...because I remember I was following a game where he attacked another player for doing so.
He then proceeds to explain why he thought the vote was bad -
If you think that's scummy, rezombied, then why are you doing it? Was your view on random voting w/out reasoning changed?
I also don't like his vote on Burning_Earth:
He's voting him for a different reason rather than barning the reasoning already presented against Burning_Earth, which I find scummy.
I dislike the flavorgaming and cult-fearmongering going on w/Burning_Earth's claim.
And I completely agree with DCIII's second post. I think rezombied is repeating his scum meta from Apocalypse.
Why are you guys trying to fish more information out of Burning_Earth's claim?
To clarify for the mod -
Vote rezombied
It was in response to:
I hadn't refreshed in ~15 minutes, so there are posts in between.
a) "No more jokes" was stated to Void, not Burning Earth
b) "No more jokes" was a joke - it seems like that should be obvious given the few posts after that one.
No. See above. You're completely misreading me.
A: their mtgs username is not in fact included in my PM
B: We have a QT and I am not sure if we are allowed to quote. Asking mod now.
A town neighbour is my role dude, just saying
Ah, alright.
Really? I didn't interpret it as such.
More to the point, what are you doing? I've looked at your posts and 60% of them are fluff, with the other 40% of them pushing and prodding Burning Earth.
No reaction to his claim + my defense? No thoughts on the other players in the thread?
Why did you respond to my accusations about you immediately and not to DCIII's?
@mod could you link to this in the waypoints post please?