how about if the cop investigates me? then if i come up scum you can lynch me but if i come up town you guys will get off my back and look for someone else.
This is heavy godfather play. Now granted, people will probably say that this is me barning Yare (being that he already touched on this), but this is the first time that I have checked the thread since my last post and I would also like to say this, and elaborate on my position. People may also say that me pointing this out may look scummy because I don't like the idea of masons in a newb game, and godfathers can throw the game out of balance as well. However, if we lynch kman and discover that he is the godfather, we can say that there may be masons because the masons and the godfather could balance the teams out. So, we could validate the masons and put the town ahead at the same time. As such, I will Unvote, Vote Kman1474.
I'm really not a fan of your defeatist attitude. In alice mafia you played this defeatist bs, and turned out to be mafia. unvote, vote kman. I don't understand why you refuse to effectiviley defend yourself.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Official Moderator of The [Gutter]
Think the MtgStaff is just swell? Join today! You too can be involved in an 8 year grudge and delete nearly 9000 of kpaca's posts!
I'm really not a fan of your defeatist attitude. In alice mafia you played this defeatist bs, and turned out to be mafia. unvote, vote kman. I don't understand why you refuse to effectiviley defend yourself.
i don't know what to defend myself from. do you have any ideas?
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Life moves pretty fast sometimes, if you don't stop
and look around every once and a while you could miss it. - ferris bueller
I HAVE DEFENDED MYSELF OVER AND OVER AGAIN!!!
i have defended myself for all of those points already so if you don't like them then just lynch me and get me out of this game!
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Life moves pretty fast sometimes, if you don't stop
and look around every once and a while you could miss it. - ferris bueller
I HAVE DEFENDED MYSELF OVER AND OVER AGAIN!!!
i have defended myself for all of those points already so if you don't like them then just lynch me and get me out of this game!
My reasoning precisely. I have read the thread and the points raised by ced395. This is not a hammer post, nor a speed lynch - I waited for a response by kman1474, but instead there was only flailing (as was pointed out).
That, good sirs, looks like a lynch.
I'm still not 100% on kman, although his rather lacklustre defence has pushed him into the red. I wasn't confident enough to hammer, but Ace has done it anyway.
depnding on how kman comes up, I think Bilbroxian and Ace are the top investigation targets. I hope the doc is on his toes, such that I may outlive the night with useful information.
adieu kman.
That, good sirs, looks like a lynch.
I'm still not 100% on kman, although his rather lacklustre defence has pushed him into the red. I wasn't confident enough to hammer, but Ace has done it anyway.
depnding on how kman comes up, I think Bilbroxian and Ace are the top investigation targets. I hope the doc is on his toes, such that I may outlive the night with useful information.
adieu kman.
Agreed. I was worried that it would set me up for a potential scum hammer, but I felt, that with the evidence, it was necessary to end the day.
After sending fresh food into the pit of baking soda and having another comrade snatched up by Joe suddenly, the food in the fridge has gotten rather restless.
"Something about kman just plain stinks," ced says.
"Yeah, he doesn't even look appetizing," snorts Yare.
"Well, that's because I'm Chinese food. I may not smell or look good, but I taste great. Honest!" kman pleads.
"Pff! Enough of this foolishness!" Ace shouts as he boots kman off the shelf and into the cripser, where the remains of hshadowa lie in a dusty pile of baking soda. Kman falls to his doom, never to be eaten properly. As he lands with a thud, his cute little white container pops open and his ricey guts spill all over. You look at each other nervously. "Oh dear, kman was Chinese Take-Out, Vanilla Townie after all."
It is now night. Please submit your actions to me by midnight CST Wednesday.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
The Golden Rule of forums: If you're going to be rude, be right. If you might be wrong, be polite.
The light flips off for a few moments of rest, and when it comes back on you quickly spot ced395 twitching on the glassy shelf. He's covered in chunky, stinking goo and he reeks to high heaven. Only one thing to do: you all pitch in and shove him unceremoniously off the shelf and down into the baking soda-filled cripser where his odors will be absorbed and hopefully spare the rest of you. As he falls, you finally get a good look at him. He's black and squishy looking - surely rotten, you think. But then it becomes clear he is in fact The Lonely Banana, Vanilla Town. His peel looks rotten long before his inside goes bad, and as he plunks into the drawer you can tell he is firm and fresh.
The situation is looking dire.
It is now day 3.
With 8 alive it is 5 to lynch.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
The Golden Rule of forums: If you're going to be rude, be right. If you might be wrong, be polite.
Alas, my investigation upon Ace was roleblocked (I was too overwhelmed by a cloud of fumes that I couldn't pick out an individual's scent)
So the only thing we can gather is that the mafia do indeed have a roleblocker.
So does that mean that because ace thought he would be investigated and therefore outed as Mafia, he threw a Roleblock at you so that you couldn't confirm it?
I'm pretty sure they would have roleblocked me anyway. they didn't know I would target Ace, and the argument above applies regardless. Maybe the mafia threw a roleblock at me to make ace seem more suspicious?
I think you are WIFOM-ing.
Well, the fact that ace already seemed suspicious doesn't help much. Also, the fact that the mafia has a roleblocker doesn't node well for us, being that the roleblocker will most likely go for Ecophagy at least until the doc dies.
So does that mean that because ace thought he would be investigated and therefore outed as Mafia, he threw a Roleblock at you so that you couldn't confirm it?
It could mean any number of things. The most logical thing for a roleblocker to do would be to roleblock the cop - it makes sense, from all points of view.
Well, the fact that ace already seemed suspicious doesn't help much. Also, the fact that the mafia has a roleblocker doesn't node well for us, being that the roleblocker will most likely go for Ecophagy at least until the doc dies.
And this. The cop's role is essentially nulled as long as the roleblocker is around, and it allows for the mafia's reign to continue.
On the positive side, with three of the eight 'clear', a post-by-post analysis of the remaining five should yield results.
Barring the possibility that the masons hoodwinked everyone, which at this point seems only about .0001375% likely to happen, these three people are scum.
Ikkleste posts just barely enough to seem townish and keep himself out of the limelight. Too me he offers no major content and is doing a good job of lurking without actually telegraphing how much he's lurking.
Bilbroxain to me says things that he trys to frame as town, but to me most of his actions have an underlying scum tone.
Ace- if he's not scum I'll eat my shoe.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Official Moderator of The [Gutter]
Think the MtgStaff is just swell? Join today! You too can be involved in an 8 year grudge and delete nearly 9000 of kpaca's posts!
the general consensus seems to be Ace is scum; why don't we apply some pressure and see what he has to say? vote: Ace
I am not terribly suspicious of ikkleste, he strikes me as town, but kpaca less so. Not sure on Sephiroth, and Bilbroxian is somewhat scummy...
So does that mean that because ace thought he would be investigated and therefore outed as Mafia, he threw a Roleblock at you so that you couldn't confirm it?
Wait...why would it have to be Ace doing the roleblocking? There seems to be an incredible presumption in this statement.
EBWOP: Yare, he doens't say Ace is roleblocker; if he is mafia he could have communicated with the other mafia members, and organised the mafia roleblock on me.
I still think Seph's argument is invalid because you could argue the same regardless of who I investigated (indeed, it could have been anyone who I could have investigated anyway)
Because ace had been mentioned in posts asking eco to investigate him on day 2. It doesn't seem too much of a presumption to me.
Oh oh. Ok, I understand. I thought there was a suggestion there that Ace must have been the one doing the roleblocking. Of course, the only people that could know that with certainty would be the scum.
-------
Note that I think we are in a lynch or lose situation, as there are only 8 people left.
pretty much, unless the doc becomes miracle worker...
That fact hadn't crossed my mind, so we need to be certain for this lynch...
eep.
And with that, the incredible irony came to light. I see no other choice than to reveal myself at this point, as I am so close to being lynched.
I am Honey, Town Doctor. As a natural preservative, I protect against food going rotten.
Night 1, I had no clue who could be cop. I went with a long-shot and smeared Yare with my honey-goodness, as I assumed that a fresh perspective on the game may have hurt the mafia more than it would us.
I attempted to stay out of the spotlight both days, and attempted to be a tad scummy so I would remain useful to the scum as a bandwagon for later days (allowing me a little longer to protect the cop (and others).
Night 2 I lathered Eco with myself (ew...), but obviously the mafia had other ideas (having a roleblocker and all), and decided to off the clear, ced.
Here I stand at -2, and so I see no other choice but to reveal myself and hope that the town now takes a stab at one of the remaining few, and hits scum.
I fully expect to die tonight, but not without giving the town my story.
Actually, seeing as how we've already outed the cop and the doc, I think it is time for a mass claim. I don't think there is too much left for the town to hide.
Actually, seeing as how we've already outed the cop and the doc, I think it is time for a mass claim. I don't think there is too much left for the town to hide.
I want roles and names.
A good point, we can't be hiding any more power roles.
I am a half filled and open can of beer. I'm definetly flat and no longer drinkable, but as a beer I'm not stinking up the fridge with rotten food smell.
unvote: vote bilbroxain, because he is second on my scum list, and it appears as if people aren't comfortable voting for ikkleste, but that will likely be taken care of tomorrow.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Official Moderator of The [Gutter]
Think the MtgStaff is just swell? Join today! You too can be involved in an 8 year grudge and delete nearly 9000 of kpaca's posts!
This is heavy godfather play. Now granted, people will probably say that this is me barning Yare (being that he already touched on this), but this is the first time that I have checked the thread since my last post and I would also like to say this, and elaborate on my position. People may also say that me pointing this out may look scummy because I don't like the idea of masons in a newb game, and godfathers can throw the game out of balance as well. However, if we lynch kman and discover that he is the godfather, we can say that there may be masons because the masons and the godfather could balance the teams out. So, we could validate the masons and put the town ahead at the same time. As such, I will Unvote, Vote Kman1474.
Many thanks to Sgt. Chubbz of Damnation studios.
and look around every once and a while you could miss it. - ferris bueller
I concur.
Magic Rules Advisor
How Creatures Die
Targets | Triggered Abilities | Priority and the Stack | Older Articles
"the off"?
Magic Rules Advisor
How Creatures Die
Targets | Triggered Abilities | Priority and the Stack | Older Articles
i don't know what to defend myself from. do you have any ideas?
and look around every once and a while you could miss it. - ferris bueller
i have defended myself for all of those points already so if you don't like them then just lynch me and get me out of this game!
and look around every once and a while you could miss it. - ferris bueller
Flialing? Possibly?
Many thanks to Sgt. Chubbz of Damnation studios.
Ask and you shall receive:
kman1474 - 5 (ced395, Yare, Bilbroxain, kpaca, Sephiroth Owa)
With 10 alive it's 6 to lynch.
Current New Favorite Person™: Mallory Archer
She knows why.
My reasoning precisely. I have read the thread and the points raised by ced395. This is not a hammer post, nor a speed lynch - I waited for a response by kman1474, but instead there was only flailing (as was pointed out).
vote kman1474
I'm still not 100% on kman, although his rather lacklustre defence has pushed him into the red. I wasn't confident enough to hammer, but Ace has done it anyway.
depnding on how kman comes up, I think Bilbroxian and Ace are the top investigation targets. I hope the doc is on his toes, such that I may outlive the night with useful information.
adieu kman.
Agreed. I was worried that it would set me up for a potential scum hammer, but I felt, that with the evidence, it was necessary to end the day.
I'm pretty sure one of us masons are going to die. Hopefully see you by next sunlight.
kman1474 - 5 (ced395, Yare, Bilbroxain, kpaca, Sephiroth Owa, Ace)
After sending fresh food into the pit of baking soda and having another comrade snatched up by Joe suddenly, the food in the fridge has gotten rather restless.
"Something about kman just plain stinks," ced says.
"Yeah, he doesn't even look appetizing," snorts Yare.
"Well, that's because I'm Chinese food. I may not smell or look good, but I taste great. Honest!" kman pleads.
"Pff! Enough of this foolishness!" Ace shouts as he boots kman off the shelf and into the cripser, where the remains of hshadowa lie in a dusty pile of baking soda. Kman falls to his doom, never to be eaten properly. As he lands with a thud, his cute little white container pops open and his ricey guts spill all over. You look at each other nervously. "Oh dear, kman was Chinese Take-Out, Vanilla Townie after all."
It is now night. Please submit your actions to me by midnight CST Wednesday.
Current New Favorite Person™: Mallory Archer
She knows why.
The situation is looking dire.
It is now day 3.
With 8 alive it is 5 to lynch.
Current New Favorite Person™: Mallory Archer
She knows why.
Get a sight on someone last night eco?
Of course. That's because you're mafia.
Vote Ace
Actually, it's because he was clear right?
Guess expressing obvious logic is stupid, huh?
Magic Rules Advisor
How Creatures Die
Targets | Triggered Abilities | Priority and the Stack | Older Articles
So the only thing we can gather is that the mafia do indeed have a roleblocker.
I'm pretty sure they would have roleblocked me anyway. they didn't know I would target Ace, and the argument above applies regardless. Maybe the mafia threw a roleblock at me to make ace seem more suspicious?
I think you are WIFOM-ing.
Many thanks to Sgt. Chubbz of Damnation studios.
It could mean any number of things. The most logical thing for a roleblocker to do would be to roleblock the cop - it makes sense, from all points of view.
And this. The cop's role is essentially nulled as long as the roleblocker is around, and it allows for the mafia's reign to continue.
On the positive side, with three of the eight 'clear', a post-by-post analysis of the remaining five should yield results.
bilbroxain
Ace
Barring the possibility that the masons hoodwinked everyone, which at this point seems only about .0001375% likely to happen, these three people are scum.
Ikkleste posts just barely enough to seem townish and keep himself out of the limelight. Too me he offers no major content and is doing a good job of lurking without actually telegraphing how much he's lurking.
Bilbroxain to me says things that he trys to frame as town, but to me most of his actions have an underlying scum tone.
Ace- if he's not scum I'll eat my shoe.
I am not terribly suspicious of ikkleste, he strikes me as town, but kpaca less so. Not sure on Sephiroth, and Bilbroxian is somewhat scummy...
Wait...why would it have to be Ace doing the roleblocking? There seems to be an incredible presumption in this statement.
Magic Rules Advisor
How Creatures Die
Targets | Triggered Abilities | Priority and the Stack | Older Articles
i think we should wait for Ace to defend himself, lest mafia jump on the wagon and speed lynch him.
I still think Seph's argument is invalid because you could argue the same regardless of who I investigated (indeed, it could have been anyone who I could have investigated anyway)
Oh oh. Ok, I understand. I thought there was a suggestion there that Ace must have been the one doing the roleblocking. Of course, the only people that could know that with certainty would be the scum.
-------
Note that I think we are in a lynch or lose situation, as there are only 8 people left.
I will have more thoughts later.
Magic Rules Advisor
How Creatures Die
Targets | Triggered Abilities | Priority and the Stack | Older Articles
pretty much, unless the doc becomes miracle worker...
That fact hadn't crossed my mind, so we need to be certain for this lynch...
eep.
And with that, the incredible irony came to light. I see no other choice than to reveal myself at this point, as I am so close to being lynched.
I am Honey, Town Doctor. As a natural preservative, I protect against food going rotten.
Night 1, I had no clue who could be cop. I went with a long-shot and smeared Yare with my honey-goodness, as I assumed that a fresh perspective on the game may have hurt the mafia more than it would us.
I attempted to stay out of the spotlight both days, and attempted to be a tad scummy so I would remain useful to the scum as a bandwagon for later days (allowing me a little longer to protect the cop (and others).
Night 2 I lathered Eco with myself (ew...), but obviously the mafia had other ideas (having a roleblocker and all), and decided to off the clear, ced.
Here I stand at -2, and so I see no other choice but to reveal myself and hope that the town now takes a stab at one of the remaining few, and hits scum.
I fully expect to die tonight, but not without giving the town my story.
Magic Rules Advisor
How Creatures Die
Targets | Triggered Abilities | Priority and the Stack | Older Articles
No, the message simply said that there was no way you were going rotten tonight.
Same deal as with the message regarding Eco. So, no go there.
So "no, I don't know if I prevented the kill" as opposed to "no, I did not prevent the kill"?
Magic Rules Advisor
How Creatures Die
Targets | Triggered Abilities | Priority and the Stack | Older Articles
No, I don't know if I prevented the kill.
However, assuming you are alive it was either a save or scum chose/forgot to nightkill.
that is a very convincing claim indeed. Any Counterclaims?
looks like you have some shoe-eating to do
vote:kpaca
Sephiroth Owa
Kpaca
Bilbroxain
ikkleste
Magic Rules Advisor
How Creatures Die
Targets | Triggered Abilities | Priority and the Stack | Older Articles
Assuming all role claims are true, this is the case. I say ikkleste is the least scummy of the above, and kpaca the most.
Also, Sephiroth, can you explain your reduced activity on day 2?
I want roles and names.
Magic Rules Advisor
How Creatures Die
Targets | Triggered Abilities | Priority and the Stack | Older Articles
Magic Rules Advisor
How Creatures Die
Targets | Triggered Abilities | Priority and the Stack | Older Articles
A good point, we can't be hiding any more power roles.
Massclaim seconded.
I am a half filled and open can of beer. I'm definetly flat and no longer drinkable, but as a beer I'm not stinking up the fridge with rotten food smell.
unvote: vote bilbroxain, because he is second on my scum list, and it appears as if people aren't comfortable voting for ikkleste, but that will likely be taken care of tomorrow.
Yes i will be eating my shoe shortly.
Magic Rules Advisor
How Creatures Die
Targets | Triggered Abilities | Priority and the Stack | Older Articles
Also major FOS: Sephiroth Owa for bandwagoing without a case and trying to speed lynch in a critical part of the game.