Also I've been reading the thread from day 1 again and I still feel like TMM is the scummiest person at the moment. He makes a slip up on page 4 I'll refer to again since no one seems to think it's a mistake on his part. I'll do a PBPA on TMM and Arcadic.
Arcadic I've responded to all of your posts. If I'm missing some then point them out cuz you're not going to win this battle
Also I've been reading the thread from day 1 again and I still feel like TMM is the scummiest person at the moment. He makes a slip up on page 4 I'll refer to again since no one seems to think it's a mistake on his part. I'll do a PBPA on TMM and Arcadic.
Arcadic I've responded to all of your posts. If I'm missing some then point them out cuz you're not going to win this battle
I never intended to win the battle. My pbpa did exactly what i wanted, it showed that your infallable and that this game is practicly in your hands at this point. It also proved that regardless of what i could do to clear myself, everyones made up their mind. The only curiousity i got outta my pbpa was your reaction.
I'll wait to say more on the Jobie wagon till Dagger says something. I do agree on TMM.
How do those two parts make any sense? You agree that one of you and Powerrox is scum, but you think Arcadic is the lynch for today? *ERROR: Does not compute*
From my PoV PowerRox must be scum. However, based on roles it's 50:50 for everyone else. From my PoV the vanillas are effectively 50:50. Since I think we can toss Khorney out as he's acted crazily super townie, it brings the chances of finding scum blindly to 66:33 OR from how I see it: Vanilla Town Claimed:
Khorney: Town
atlseal: Town (confirmed, since I 99% believe blue's claim)
Arcadic :Scum
TMM: Neutral
vezok : Neutral
PRs Claimed
blue: Cop - Town
Jobie: 1-shot JoaT, unused - Town
Powerrox: Backup PR, now Doc - Scum
So Arcadic, PowerRox, and one of Vezok and TMM are scum from my PoV. I think Arcadic is the scummiest of the 4, hence why I think he's today's lynch despite role information making me assume PowerRox is scum.
@atlseal: Between Myself and Arcadic who is more sure to be scum in your eyes?
Arcadic is more scummy by far, but he is not the RBer. You are scummy, and there's a good chance you are the RBer. Under normal circumstances, I'd be going after Arcadic first, but the situation dictates my need to lynch you first.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
If you're town and I'm mafia, you've already lost. You just don't know it yet.
Arcadic is more scummy by far, but he is not the RBer. You are scummy, and there's a good chance you are the RBer. Under normal circumstances, I'd be going after Arcadic first, but the situation dictates my need to lynch you first.
Why does me having an ability predispose me to be the RBer?
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Mafia Stats (10-22 Overall) Random Mafia 2 Town MVP '08 MTGS Fantasy Football Overall Champion Best Non-SK Neutral Performance (Individual)
Games:
Basic 26: Alive : Won
Basic 24: Dead : Lost
Southpark mafia: Dead : draw?
Basic 28: Dead :
Basic 30: Alive :
Annorax's Not-very-Bastard Mod Mafia: Alive
Also, I am now ok with voting for Jobie for today...If he insists his claims are real, but yet, there are two PR's which disagree (the back up and Power), it's obvious he is lying and could indeed be a scum rb. I won't cast my vote until:
1) we all agree (to prevent speedy lynch)
2) Jobie presents his Arcadic case
Games:
Basic 26: Alive : Won
Basic 24: Dead : Lost
Southpark mafia: Dead : draw?
Basic 28: Dead :
Basic 30: Alive :
Annorax's Not-very-Bastard Mod Mafia: Alive
MOD: Is this against the spirit of the rules? It seems like a loophole that should have been closed. There's obvious information outside the thread by a replaced player.
While it is frowned upon to make any sort of assumption or mod-gaming of that nature, it is entirely a player's prerogative if he or she wishes to do so, whether said assumption is accurate or inaccurate.
Games:
Basic 26: Alive : Won
Basic 24: Dead : Lost
Southpark mafia: Dead : draw?
Basic 28: Dead :
Basic 30: Alive :
Annorax's Not-very-Bastard Mod Mafia: Alive
U can't touch this
U can't touch this
U can't touch this
U can't touch this
My-my-my-my (U can't touch this) music hits me so hard
Makes me say,"oh my lord thank you for blessing me
With a mind to rhyme and two hyped feet"
It feels good
When you know you're sown
A superdope homeboy from the Oaktown
And I'm known as such
And this is a beat-uh!
U can't touch this
I told you homeboy
U can't touch this
Yeah, that's how we livin' and you know
U can't touch this
Look in my eyes,man
U can't touch this
Yo, let me bust the funky lyrics
U can't touch this
Fresh new kicks and pants
You got it like that now you know you wanna dance
So move out of your seat
And get a fly girl and catch this beat
While it's rolling
Hold on
Pump a little bit and let 'em know it's going on
Like that
Like that
Cold on a mission so fall on back
Let 'em know that you're too much
And this is a beat
They can't touch
Yo! I told you
U can't touch this
Why you standing there, man?
U can't touch this
Yo,sound the bells, school is in, sucker
U can't touch this
Give me a song or rhythm
Making 'em sweat
That's what I'm giving'em
Now they know
You talk about the Hammer, you're talking about a show
That's hyped and tight
Singers are sweating so pass them a wipe
Or a tape to learn
What it is going to take in the '90s
To burn the charts
Legit either work hard or you might as well quit
That's the word,because you know
U can't touch this
U can't touch this
Break it down
Stop. . . Hammer time
Go with the flow
It is said
That if you can't groove to this
Then you probably are dead
So wave your hands in the air
Bust a few moves, run your fingers through your hair
This is it for a winter
Dance to this an' you're gonna get thinner
Move slide your rump
Just for a minute, let's all do the bump
Bump bump bump
Yeah, U can't touch this
Look man, U can't touch this
You better get hyped
Boy 'cause you know ya can't
U can't touch this
Ring the bell, school's back in
Break it down
Stop. Hammer time
U can't touch this
U can't touch this
U can't touch this
U can't touch this
Break it down
Stop. Hammer time
Every time you see me
The Hammer's just so hyped
I'm dope on the floor
And I'm magic on the mike
Now why would I ever
Stop doing this?
When others making records
That just don't hit
I've toured around the world
From London to the Bay
It's Hammer, go Hammer, M.C.Hammer, Yo Hammer
And the rest can go and play
Can't touch this
U can't touch this
U can't touch this
U can't touch this
Yeah,U can't touch this
I told you, U can't touch this
Too hype, can't touch this
Yo, we outta here, can't touch this
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
If you're town and I'm mafia, you've already lost. You just don't know it yet.
Games:
Basic 26: Alive : Won
Basic 24: Dead : Lost
Southpark mafia: Dead : draw?
Basic 28: Dead :
Basic 30: Alive :
Annorax's Not-very-Bastard Mod Mafia: Alive
His eyes were darting left and right, sweeping across the chamber and its occupants.
There was a noticeable shift in the atmosphere.
Within the span of a single second, the mood went from amiable to downright edgy.
Another was slated to die.
The number of eyes staring at Jobie increased.
The number of conversations exchanged decreased.
You could see Jobie clenching his fists and biting down hard on his lips.
Tick.
Little by little.
Tick.
It was finally silent.
Jobie lunged forward, right at you, being the nearest to where he stood.
You could feel hands curling around your throat.
Gripping.
Tightening.
Choking.
You struggled for air.
Jobie screamed in defiance.
You heard nary a single word.
You could only focus on his glistening eyes.
The beginning of tears were pooling underneath.
Fear, rejection, desperation were rolling off him in waves.
Desperate.
Jobie did not intend to go down quietly.
You clawed at his hands frantically.
You needed air.
Help.
Dimly, you registered a pop.
The hands around your neck immediately slackened.
You gasped loudly.
Air.
Sweet air.
Red.
Hot and stinging.
You squeezed your eyes shut.
Metallic tang.
You spit and sputtered.
Something soft and chewy.
You retched and immediately vomited onto the ground.
You stumbled backward.
Wet.
Nauseous.
In front of you, Jobie was kneeling on the ground, hands limping by his sides and a headless neck gazing upward into the ceiling.
Blood gushing silently downward.
Red.
You nearly slipped on the now slippery floor.
Red.
Even as you continued to stumble backward into your room half-blind, a stream of information filtered into your brain.
Jobie, Mafia Vanilla has been lynched.
It was a victory for you.
For your team.
Was it?
Victory.
It must.
That was all you had now.
~~~~~
It is now Night 3.
Night 3 will last for a maximum of 72 hours. Please submit your action choices by PM before then. No posting in the game thread during the Night phase.
Hrm. So that leaves me with TMM as my prime suspect for today.
Jobie: Still unproven eh?
vote TMM
Are we still in LYLO?
This post by blue strikes my fancy...if TMM was his second suspect, and he flipped town/cop, this could be significant. As such, TMM and Arcadic are my scum suspects.
Games:
Basic 26: Alive : Won
Basic 24: Dead : Lost
Southpark mafia: Dead : draw?
Basic 28: Dead :
Basic 30: Alive :
Annorax's Not-very-Bastard Mod Mafia: Alive
So, we have confirmation that Powerrox and Altseal are town.
IMO, TMM really needs to contribute something worthwhile at this stage of the game, he's still my #1 scum target. Vezo is #2 and Khorney is #3 at this stage. I do plan on re-reading Khorney, but it may be monday at the earliest.
This post by blue strikes my fancy...if TMM was his second suspect, and he flipped town/cop, this could be significant. As such, TMM and Arcadic are my scum suspects.
Assuming standard 12 man setup, there are 2 scum left. So yes, still in LYLO. Good point on this early day 3 vote, no-one was willing to wagon and quick lynch over a good amount of time. probably a WIFOM case though.
Ahh.
We have 2 confirmed townies.
4 people in which 2 are scum left.
atlseal could stil be godfather. The amount of power in this town is too great for only one scum RBer.
We had a doc and a cop and a back up.
atlaseal is not the lynch for today.
Everyone says TMM is scum because of one of blue's posts.
He was sure he will die this night so he would have claimed if he found TMM scum.
Look at jobie's list. It's so WIFOM.
I think khorney is scum.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Thanks to DNC at Heroes of the plane studios for this awesome sig and SGT_Chubbz for the awesome avy. Check out the Shop Thread
Ok, so in my mind, the only possible combinations for scum left are:
- TMM and Arcadic
- TMM and vezok
- Arcadic and vezok
@vezok: After that last post, I'm either sure you're scum or I now completely understand why you're either lynched or vigged in every game. Can you figure out why?
More to come later.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
If you're town and I'm mafia, you've already lost. You just don't know it yet.
I've been going through the thread looking at all interactions between Jobie, vezok, Arcadic, and TMM. Not all the way through, but here's what I have so far:
[spoilers=Ending at 320 for now] Jobie:
vezok-
307: Comment on vezok's cantrip or Jobie is scum
Arcadic-
135: Meaningless argument over deriving tone through text
307: Was helping townie, answers Arcadic's question to TMM
TMM-
vezok:
Jobie-
268: Either Jobie or Cantrip is scum
Arcadic-
277: Answers arcadic 276
291: "You wouldn't random kill a potential mis lynch target.
There was some suspicion on OMJ.
They could have killed arcadic or Wataru. Or somebody else like khorney who is percieved town." => Further cements belief that vezok is not scum with Arcadic
TMM-
Arcadic:
Jobie-
275: "Jobie, i would like your reason for forcing a Claim and pushing to l-2. Feel free to quote yourself, but i didn't find a reason."
311: Notes Jobie's answer
vezok-
276: "I am curious as to what information you could get from this thread that he was the doc. The only info i could get was that i felt him as leaning town. I'm more inclined to think they just killed a town. Prove me wrong? Khorney, i also pose you the same question, since you were the inital targeter of OMJ." => Makes me believe both Arcadic and vezok are not scum together
311: Similar feelings to vezok about the kill night before
TMM-
110: Votes for /barning MandersHex on reasons
125: Clarifies position, still pretty much Manders' argument
129: Amaxing deductive skills makes TMM scum and DL town.
134: Now both TMM and DL could be scum
173: Unvotes TMM "I'm still curious about your motives, but not enough to lynch right now."
286: "Random? It seems to me that is a fairly flawed view. I ask, because your not a newbie, why would a random kill benefit the scum more than a targeted one?"
317: Agrees with TMM on 316
TMM:
Jobie-
316: Says didn't see two posts by OMJ cluing power role
vezok-
264: Calls vezoks Sep vote bad
284: "I think the conclusion that those two are scum because they happened to kill a power role is kind of dumb. It appears to just be a random kill."
Arcadic-
126: "It was as simple as me misunderstanding a noob town implosion."
133: Arcadic reading too much into statement
303: Answers "Random?" question from Arcadic. "But the way I see it, on D1 all anyone knew was a rough outline of alignment." <= Compare this to his belief of OMJ and DL day 1[/spoiler]
For me, it's enough to eliminate the vezok/Arcadic scum team. That leaves me with either:
- vezok and TMM
- Arcadic and TMM
So, Vote: TMM. Will continue analysis for rest of thread later.
By the way, Arcadic, sorry about yesterday. I was purposefully trying to get a rise out of you. When people get emotional, they make more mistakes in their posts.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
If you're town and I'm mafia, you've already lost. You just don't know it yet.
Arcadic, I have contributed (See: my pbpa on you). And the only reason I didn't contribute to the lynch effort on Jobie was because it all happened while I was volunteering at a day camp.
Stuff will come on vezok later.
Jobie:
vezok-
307: Comment on vezok's cantrip or Jobie is scum
329: "What specifically was odd about my response? I'm not a big fan of your short posts that lack causation (in other words they have content but no support)"
359: "@Vezok: What about my responses were scummy? Why are you so sure?"
361: "Huh?"
Arcadic-
135: Meaningless argument over deriving tone through text
307: Was helping townie, answers Arcadic's question to TMM
350: "I don't know of a game on MTGS where the target of a doc protection have known they are being protected.
Also, @Arcadic: Can you explain why that series of quotes are the main reason for your suspicion? I acknowledge the no-unvote was stupid and slightly scummy."
371: Answers Arcadic's questions regarding OMJ/DL posts end of Day 1
TMM-
vezok:
Jobie-
268: Either Jobie or Cantrip is scum
327: Either Jobie or Cantrip is scum, again
354: Votes Jobie after Jobie's response to blue
360: "I am sure cause I say so.
You only respond with fair enough and stuff like that."
Arcadic-
277: Answers arcadic 276
291: "You wouldn't random kill a potential mis lynch target.
There was some suspicion on OMJ.
They could have killed arcadic or Wataru. Or somebody else like khorney who is percieved town." => Further cements belief that vezok is not scum with Arcadic
342: "Blue is awesome. I am not sure about your arcadic read but we will see."
TMM-
Ending post 320:
Arcadic:
Jobie-
275: "Jobie, i would like your reason for forcing a Claim and pushing to l-2. Feel free to quote yourself, but i didn't find a reason."
311: Notes Jobie's answer
345: Votes Jobie + "D1 he tried to appear town while still pushing claims and lynch against DL. That and his failure to unvote at -1, which i didn't pickup on till it was quoted, slip you even further down the scummy trail."
370: Unvotes Jobie for reason in vezok area
vezok-
276: "I am curious as to what information you could get from this thread that he was the doc. The only info i could get was that i felt him as leaning town. I'm more inclined to think they just killed a town. Prove me wrong? Khorney, i also pose you the same question, since you were the inital targeter of OMJ." => Makes me believe both Arcadic and vezok are not scum together
311: Similar feelings to vezok about the kill night before
345: "And yes, it makes zero sense to NK OMJ, however Vezo gave a horrible reasoning why they saw to NK, a power role. IMO this shows knowledge that he was fishing for other reasons beyond a NK to take us off the trail."
370: "However, i am happy with the replies you gave blue over the last 2 pages. I would like to see some hunting from you. I also am unvoting because i do not like Vezo's /barn vote to put you at l-2. It did not end well the last time and i doubt it will this time."
TMM-
110: Votes for /barning MandersHex on reasons
125: Clarifies position, still pretty much Manders' argument
129: Amaxing deductive skills makes TMM scum and DL town.
134: Now both TMM and DL could be scum
173: Unvotes TMM "I'm still curious about your motives, but not enough to lynch right now."
286: "Random? It seems to me that is a fairly flawed view. I ask, because your not a newbie, why would a random kill benefit the scum more than a targeted one?"
317: Agrees with TMM on 316
TMM:
Jobie-
316: Says didn't see two posts by OMJ cluing power role
372: Thinks misunderstanding with Jobie. Content to sit and watch
408: "Huh, I've never actually seen a Jack of All Trades role ever. Is this stuff legit?
I'm inclined to believe his claim, however I don't understand how the role is possible." <= Damning evidence
vezok-
264: Calls vezoks Sep vote bad
284: "I think the conclusion that those two are scum because they happened to kill a power role is kind of dumb. It appears to just be a random kill."
325: Questions vezok's Seppel vote
368: "This is honestly the worst bandwagon jump I have ever seen." (in reference to vezok's vote on Jobie)
438 - "So you want him to find you scummy?
I know enough to know that's just how you play town -- many posts with little to no content and bad votes. It is what it is I suppose."
Arcadic-
126: "It was as simple as me misunderstanding a noob town implosion."
133: Arcadic reading too much into statement
303: Answers "Random?" question from Arcadic. "But the way I see it, on D1 all anyone knew was a rough outline of alignment." <= Compare this to his belief of OMJ and DL day 1
----------------------------------------
In resposne to Sep claiming he was RBed, vezok posts:
"No. It wasn't a good time.
That was dumb." <= Auto-assumes Sep was telling the truth
Then, later:
"In this game apparently you get flavor for being targetted even if you don't have a PR. At least I am hoping for that cause if not that means Sepiriel is a a PR." <= carried on here
---------------------------
I'm actually becoming convinced that the last two scum are vezok and TMM.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
If you're town and I'm mafia, you've already lost. You just don't know it yet.
Ok, now I'm almost completely convinced vezok and TMM are our last scum.
Jobie: vezok-
307: Comment on vezok's cantrip or Jobie is scum
329: "What specifically was odd about my response? I'm not a big fan of your short posts that lack causation (in other words they have content but no support)"
359: "@Vezok: What about my responses were scummy? Why are you so sure?"
361: "Huh?"
533: Willing to shoot vezok
538: "@Vezok: You don't seem angry to me, just blunt and I appreciate it. (no sarcasm, intended)"
Arcadic-
135: Meaningless argument over deriving tone through text
307: Was helping townie, answers Arcadic's question to TMM
350: "I don't know of a game on MTGS where the target of a doc protection have known they are being protected.
Also, @Arcadic: Can you explain why that series of quotes are the main reason for your suspicion? I acknowledge the no-unvote was stupid and slightly scummy."
371: Answers Arcadic's questions regarding OMJ/DL posts end of Day 1
533: Willing to shoot Arcadic
658: Points out Arcadic trying to make blue look scummy
682: "Lynch Arcadic. Lynching me is a loss for the town. (See what I did there?)"
TMM-
533: Willing to shoot TMM
vezok: Jobie-
268: Either Jobie or Cantrip is scum
327: Either Jobie or Cantrip is scum, again
354: Votes Jobie after Jobie's response to blue
360: "I am sure cause I say so.
You only respond with fair enough and stuff like that."
520: Tells Jobie to use Vig
524: "Jobie kills tonight. If the flavor doesn't matches what he said it's clear he is lying."
534: Jobie, vig someone
673: Lynch Jobie today
695: "Time is up scum. You die."
Arcadic-
277: Answers arcadic 276
291: "You wouldn't random kill a potential mis lynch target.
There was some suspicion on OMJ.
They could have killed arcadic or Wataru. Or somebody else like khorney who is percieved town." => Further cements belief that vezok is not scum with Arcadic
342: "Blue is awesome. I am not sure about your arcadic read but we will see."
511: "If arcadic does and you flip town he will die." (hammering Sep next time he gets on)
660: Wants to lynch Arcadic
TMM-
710: "Everyone says TMM is scum because of one of blue's posts."?
Arcadic: Jobie-
275: "Jobie, i would like your reason for forcing a Claim and pushing to l-2. Feel free to quote yourself, but i didn't find a reason."
311: Notes Jobie's answer
345: Votes Jobie + "D1 he tried to appear town while still pushing claims and lynch against DL. That and his failure to unvote at -1, which i didn't pickup on till it was quoted, slip you even further down the scummy trail."
370: Unvotes Jobie for reason in vezok area
560: Fine with Jobie vigging self or TMM
677: Jobie is lynch for the day
vezok-
276: "I am curious as to what information you could get from this thread that he was the doc. The only info i could get was that i felt him as leaning town. I'm more inclined to think they just killed a town. Prove me wrong? Khorney, i also pose you the same question, since you were the inital targeter of OMJ." => Makes me believe both Arcadic and vezok are not scum together
311: Similar feelings to vezok about the kill night before
345: "And yes, it makes zero sense to NK OMJ, however Vezo gave a horrible reasoning why they saw to NK, a power role. IMO this shows knowledge that he was fishing for other reasons beyond a NK to take us off the trail."
370: "However, i am happy with the replies you gave blue over the last 2 pages. I would like to see some hunting from you. I also am unvoting because i do not like Vezo's /barn vote to put you at l-2. It did not end well the last time and i doubt it will this time."
707: TMM top scum suspect, vezok 2nd
TMM-
110: Votes for /barning MandersHex on reasons
125: Clarifies position, still pretty much Manders' argument
129: Amaxing deductive skills makes TMM scum and DL town.
134: Now both TMM and DL could be scum
173: Unvotes TMM "I'm still curious about your motives, but not enough to lynch right now."
286: "Random? It seems to me that is a fairly flawed view. I ask, because your not a newbie, why would a random kill benefit the scum more than a targeted one?"
317: Agrees with TMM on 316
560: Fine with Jobie vigging self or TMM
707: TMM top scum suspect, vezok 2nd
TMM: Jobie-
316: Says didn't see two posts by OMJ cluing power role
372: Thinks misunderstanding with Jobie. Content to sit and watch
408: "Huh, I've never actually seen a Jack of All Trades role ever. Is this stuff legit?
I'm inclined to believe his claim, however I don't understand how the role is possible." <= Damning evidence
442: Likes blue's case on Jobie, wants to wait for Jobie to respond
556: Case for Arcadic Vig
674: "I feel Arcadic is the right lynch for today, but I wouldn't be against a Jobie wagon if it arose."
vezok-
264: Calls vezoks Sep vote bad
284: "I think the conclusion that those two are scum because they happened to kill a power role is kind of dumb. It appears to just be a random kill."
325: Questions vezok's Seppel vote
368: "This is honestly the worst bandwagon jump I have ever seen." (in reference to vezok's vote on Jobie)
438 - "So you want him to find you scummy?
I know enough to know that's just how you play town -- many posts with little to no content and bad votes. It is what it is I suppose."
713: Will case vezok later
Arcadic-
126: "It was as simple as me misunderstanding a noob town implosion."
133: Arcadic reading too much into statement
303: Answers "Random?" question from Arcadic. "But the way I see it, on D1 all anyone knew was a rough outline of alignment." <= Compare this to his belief of OMJ and DL day 1
540: "I would recommend Arcadic for a vig. I don't like the way he's been playing."
562: "If I get vigged, I would still like for you to reply to them." [His points for Arcadic vig]
674: "I feel Arcadic is the right lynch for today, but I wouldn't be against a Jobie wagon if it arose."
713: Mentions his case on Arcadic as contribution
TL;DR: Both Jobie and vezok have pretty much failed to acknowledge that TMM is even playing in this game. Look at Jobie's only interaction with TMM. He offers to shoot him with no mention of TMM before or after that. Vezok just mentions TMM for the first time today in defense of him.
I'm happy with TMM lynch today, vezok goes tomorrow.
THE END
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
If you're town and I'm mafia, you've already lost. You just don't know it yet.
VOTE TMM Your right about vezo as well. He totally just outted himself with his last post.
If you're going to barn, at least add something.
@atlseal: I honestly don't understand the format in which you're doing your pbpas. Could you explain? (To make reading easier)
Games:
Basic 26: Alive : Won
Basic 24: Dead : Lost
Southpark mafia: Dead : draw?
Basic 28: Dead :
Basic 30: Alive :
Annorax's Not-very-Bastard Mod Mafia: Alive
@atlseal: I honestly don't understand the format in which you're doing your pbpas. Could you explain? (To make reading easier)
Sure, I analyzed interactions between Jobie, Arcadic, vezok, and you. Any time any player made any mention or conversed with any other player, I made a note. Top level (bolded) are the origin, italicized are the destination. So for instance,
Jobie: TMM-
150: Said blah
Would mean, Jobie said blah to TMM in post 150.
Again, both Jobie and vezok have all but ignored your existence in this game. Scum often talk/debate with/about each other because they already know each other are scum. It seems as if your scum partners unwillingly outed you by ignoring you.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
If you're town and I'm mafia, you've already lost. You just don't know it yet.
Again, both Jobie and vezok have all but ignored your existence in this game. Scum often don't talk/debate with/about each other because they already know each other are scum. It seems as if your scum partners unwillingly outed you by ignoring you.
Missing the all-important word.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
If you're town and I'm mafia, you've already lost. You just don't know it yet.
Ok, I am satisfied through reading their interactions that TMM and Vez or TMM and Arc are the last scum (Maybe less on Arc). I would like to request to hammer for today, for a similar reason blue had. If you don't wish me to do so, just say, and I will submit my vote normally.
Games:
Basic 26: Alive : Won
Basic 24: Dead : Lost
Southpark mafia: Dead : draw?
Basic 28: Dead :
Basic 30: Alive :
Annorax's Not-very-Bastard Mod Mafia: Alive
Games:
Basic 26: Alive : Won
Basic 24: Dead : Lost
Southpark mafia: Dead : draw?
Basic 28: Dead :
Basic 30: Alive :
Annorax's Not-very-Bastard Mod Mafia: Alive
Games:
Basic 26: Alive : Won
Basic 24: Dead : Lost
Southpark mafia: Dead : draw?
Basic 28: Dead :
Basic 30: Alive :
Annorax's Not-very-Bastard Mod Mafia: Alive
Games:
Basic 26: Alive : Won
Basic 24: Dead : Lost
Southpark mafia: Dead : draw?
Basic 28: Dead :
Basic 30: Alive :
Annorax's Not-very-Bastard Mod Mafia: Alive
Votecount
The Muffin Man (4) - atlseal, Arcadic, Powerrox93, khorney06
With 6 Players alive, it’s 4 Players to Lynch.
As of this post, a Lynch has occurred.
~~~~~
It was simple really.
Everything was narrowed down to a single choice.
Judging from the way the wind blew, you had already moved away.
A safe distance.
And from where you stood, you looked intently at The Muffin Man.
He crouched down unmoving.
His gaze was lifeless as the verdict was given.
But he was smiling.
An empty smile.
Devoid of feelings.
Understandably, no one moved closer.
Tick.
The Muffin Man raised his hands.
Everyone tensed.
But he sat motionless.
He only held up his hands to the lights above.
And he stared at them.
Silent.
Tentatively, you raised one of your hands up as well.
And you stared at it.
You didn’t understand.
Framed by the lights, there was a corona of red tingeing the edges of your hand.
And then you did understand.
The Muffin Man then covered his head with both arms and rested them above his knees.
I’m sorry, he whispered.
It was so soft you could barely hear it.
And then he wept.
His body heaved and shook.
You closed your eyes and turned around, heading for your room.
Behind you, you heard the distinct sound of pop.
The sound of which would plague your nightmares from now on.
Even as you strode forward, a stream of information filtered into your brain.
The Muffin Man, Mafia Vanilla has been lynched.
So be it.
The metallic doors slid open.
And then there were five.
The curtains were coming down fast.
Tick.
~~~~~
It is now Night 4.
Night 4 will last for a maximum of 72 hours. Please submit your action choices by PM before then. No posting in the game thread during the Night phase.
Let's end this already. Unless vezok or khorney can provide a very good reason for me to switch my vote to Arcadic, vezok is where my vote is going to stay.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
If you're town and I'm mafia, you've already lost. You just don't know it yet.
Ahh.
We have 2 confirmed townies.
4 people in which 2 are scum left.
atlseal could stil be godfather. The amount of power in this town is too great for only one scum RBer.
We had a doc and a cop and a back up.
atlaseal is not the lynch for today.
Everyone says TMM is scum because of one of blue's posts.
He was sure he will die this night so he would have claimed if he found TMM scum.
Look at jobie's list. It's so WIFOM.
I think khorney is scum.
If you needed any proof Khorney that Vezo is scum here's the proof. Altseal was confirmed town by blue who was confirmed town at this time.
Games:
Basic 26: Alive : Won
Basic 24: Dead : Lost
Southpark mafia: Dead : draw?
Basic 28: Dead :
Basic 30: Alive :
Annorax's Not-very-Bastard Mod Mafia: Alive
I don't get what you're saying here.
Arcadic I've responded to all of your posts. If I'm missing some then point them out cuz you're not going to win this battle
I never intended to win the battle. My pbpa did exactly what i wanted, it showed that your infallable and that this game is practicly in your hands at this point. It also proved that regardless of what i could do to clear myself, everyones made up their mind. The only curiousity i got outta my pbpa was your reaction.
I'll wait to say more on the Jobie wagon till Dagger says something. I do agree on TMM.
My wife was on MTV with this video.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BUutIZg2EpU
Vanilla Town Claimed:
Khorney: Town
atlseal: Town (confirmed, since I 99% believe blue's claim)
Arcadic :Scum
TMM: Neutral
vezok : Neutral
PRs Claimed
blue: Cop - Town
Jobie: 1-shot JoaT, unused - Town
Powerrox: Backup PR, now Doc - Scum
So Arcadic, PowerRox, and one of Vezok and TMM are scum from my PoV. I think Arcadic is the scummiest of the 4, hence why I think he's today's lynch despite role information making me assume PowerRox is scum.
Lynch Arcadic. Lynching me is a loss for the town. (See what I did there?)
Yes
@atlseal: Between Myself and Arcadic who is more sure to be scum in your eyes?
PBPA on Arcadic still coming.
Random Mafia 2 Town MVP
'08 MTGS Fantasy Football Overall Champion
Best Non-SK Neutral Performance (Individual)
Arcadic is more scummy by far, but he is not the RBer. You are scummy, and there's a good chance you are the RBer. Under normal circumstances, I'd be going after Arcadic first, but the situation dictates my need to lynch you first.
My wife was on MTV with this video.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BUutIZg2EpU
Random Mafia 2 Town MVP
'08 MTGS Fantasy Football Overall Champion
Best Non-SK Neutral Performance (Individual)
The best lies are sprinkled with truth instead of a complete fabrication.
Random Mafia 2 Town MVP
'08 MTGS Fantasy Football Overall Champion
Best Non-SK Neutral Performance (Individual)
Random Mafia 2 Town MVP
'08 MTGS Fantasy Football Overall Champion
Best Non-SK Neutral Performance (Individual)
Did anyone mention escaping their cells? If not...inside knowledge?
Games:
Basic 26: Alive : Won
Basic 24: Dead : Lost
Southpark mafia: Dead : draw?
Basic 28: Dead :
Basic 30: Alive :
Annorax's Not-very-Bastard Mod Mafia: Alive
By: Krackshott of Kracked Graphics
1) we all agree (to prevent speedy lynch)
2) Jobie presents his Arcadic case
Games:
Basic 26: Alive : Won
Basic 24: Dead : Lost
Southpark mafia: Dead : draw?
Basic 28: Dead :
Basic 30: Alive :
Annorax's Not-very-Bastard Mod Mafia: Alive
By: Krackshott of Kracked Graphics
Jobie (1) - atlseal
With 8 Players alive, it's 5 Players to Lynch.
While it is frowned upon to make any sort of assumption or mod-gaming of that nature, it is entirely a player's prerogative if he or she wishes to do so, whether said assumption is accurate or inaccurate.
We'll make you an offer you can't refuse.
Hosting: Vista Mafia
Hosted: Intrigue Mafia (Mini), Seance #43 (Basic), Conflux Mafia (Normal), Goo Mafia (FTQ), Experiment #26 (Basic)
Ongoing/Completed - 0/41
Town/Mafia/SK/Survivor - 30/6/4/1
NKed/Lynched/Survived - 15/11/15
My commands also go through a microchip
Time is up scum. You die.
Thanks to DNC at Heroes of the plane studios for this awesome sig and SGT_Chubbz for the awesome avy.
Check out the Shop Thread
Games:
Basic 26: Alive : Won
Basic 24: Dead : Lost
Southpark mafia: Dead : draw?
Basic 28: Dead :
Basic 30: Alive :
Annorax's Not-very-Bastard Mod Mafia: Alive
By: Krackshott of Kracked Graphics
U can't touch this
U can't touch this
U can't touch this
My-my-my-my (U can't touch this) music hits me so hard
Makes me say,"oh my lord thank you for blessing me
With a mind to rhyme and two hyped feet"
It feels good
When you know you're sown
A superdope homeboy from the Oaktown
And I'm known as such
And this is a beat-uh!
U can't touch this
I told you homeboy
U can't touch this
Yeah, that's how we livin' and you know
U can't touch this
Look in my eyes,man
U can't touch this
Yo, let me bust the funky lyrics
U can't touch this
Fresh new kicks and pants
You got it like that now you know you wanna dance
So move out of your seat
And get a fly girl and catch this beat
While it's rolling
Hold on
Pump a little bit and let 'em know it's going on
Like that
Like that
Cold on a mission so fall on back
Let 'em know that you're too much
And this is a beat
They can't touch
Yo! I told you
U can't touch this
Why you standing there, man?
U can't touch this
Yo,sound the bells, school is in, sucker
U can't touch this
Give me a song or rhythm
Making 'em sweat
That's what I'm giving'em
Now they know
You talk about the Hammer, you're talking about a show
That's hyped and tight
Singers are sweating so pass them a wipe
Or a tape to learn
What it is going to take in the '90s
To burn the charts
Legit either work hard or you might as well quit
That's the word,because you know
U can't touch this
U can't touch this
Break it down
Stop. . . Hammer time
Go with the flow
It is said
That if you can't groove to this
Then you probably are dead
So wave your hands in the air
Bust a few moves, run your fingers through your hair
This is it for a winter
Dance to this an' you're gonna get thinner
Move slide your rump
Just for a minute, let's all do the bump
Bump bump bump
Yeah, U can't touch this
Look man, U can't touch this
You better get hyped
Boy 'cause you know ya can't
U can't touch this
Ring the bell, school's back in
Break it down
Stop. Hammer time
U can't touch this
U can't touch this
U can't touch this
U can't touch this
Break it down
Stop. Hammer time
Every time you see me
The Hammer's just so hyped
I'm dope on the floor
And I'm magic on the mike
Now why would I ever
Stop doing this?
When others making records
That just don't hit
I've toured around the world
From London to the Bay
It's Hammer, go Hammer, M.C.Hammer, Yo Hammer
And the rest can go and play
Can't touch this
U can't touch this
U can't touch this
U can't touch this
Yeah,U can't touch this
I told you, U can't touch this
Too hype, can't touch this
Yo, we outta here, can't touch this
Games:
Basic 26: Alive : Won
Basic 24: Dead : Lost
Southpark mafia: Dead : draw?
Basic 28: Dead :
Basic 30: Alive :
Annorax's Not-very-Bastard Mod Mafia: Alive
By: Krackshott of Kracked Graphics
Jobie (5) - atlseal, blue, vezokpiraka, Powerrox93, khorney06
With 8 Players alive, it's 5 Players to Lynch.
As of this post, a Lynch has occurred.
~~~~~
Jobie tensed.
His eyes were darting left and right, sweeping across the chamber and its occupants.
There was a noticeable shift in the atmosphere.
Within the span of a single second, the mood went from amiable to downright edgy.
Another was slated to die.
The number of eyes staring at Jobie increased.
The number of conversations exchanged decreased.
You could see Jobie clenching his fists and biting down hard on his lips.
Tick.
Little by little.
Tick.
It was finally silent.
Jobie lunged forward, right at you, being the nearest to where he stood.
You could feel hands curling around your throat.
Gripping.
Tightening.
Choking.
You struggled for air.
Jobie screamed in defiance.
You heard nary a single word.
You could only focus on his glistening eyes.
The beginning of tears were pooling underneath.
Fear, rejection, desperation were rolling off him in waves.
Desperate.
Jobie did not intend to go down quietly.
You clawed at his hands frantically.
You needed air.
Help.
Dimly, you registered a pop.
The hands around your neck immediately slackened.
You gasped loudly.
Air.
Sweet air.
Red.
Hot and stinging.
You squeezed your eyes shut.
Metallic tang.
You spit and sputtered.
Something soft and chewy.
You retched and immediately vomited onto the ground.
You stumbled backward.
Wet.
Nauseous.
In front of you, Jobie was kneeling on the ground, hands limping by his sides and a headless neck gazing upward into the ceiling.
Blood gushing silently downward.
Red.
You nearly slipped on the now slippery floor.
Red.
Even as you continued to stumble backward into your room half-blind, a stream of information filtered into your brain.
Jobie, Mafia Vanilla has been lynched.
It was a victory for you.
For your team.
Was it?
Victory.
It must.
That was all you had now.
~~~~~
It is now Night 3.
Night 3 will last for a maximum of 72 hours. Please submit your action choices by PM before then. No posting in the game thread during the Night phase.
We'll make you an offer you can't refuse.
Hosting: Vista Mafia
Hosted: Intrigue Mafia (Mini), Seance #43 (Basic), Conflux Mafia (Normal), Goo Mafia (FTQ), Experiment #26 (Basic)
Ongoing/Completed - 0/41
Town/Mafia/SK/Survivor - 30/6/4/1
NKed/Lynched/Survived - 15/11/15
Random Mafia 2 Town MVP
'08 MTGS Fantasy Football Overall Champion
Best Non-SK Neutral Performance (Individual)
You were prepared for the day.
Absent-mindedly, you tugged at the loose white clothing you were wearing.
It was clean.
It smelled fresh even.
Idly, you wondered what type of detergent they were using.
And how many white clothing they actually had.
Not that it mattered of course.
You were all dead men walking.
The door slid open.
You walked through it.
A stream of information filtered into your brain.
blue,Town Cop has been killed.
Your steps did not falter.
So the cop was dead then.
Another had fallen in this sick twisted game.
You stopped in the middle of the chamber.
The headless corpse from yesterday was gone.
The floor and walls had been scrubbed clean.
No trace of blood.
How very efficient.
You looked around.
Including yours, six doors were opened.
blue’s remained closed.
The rest began to slowly emerge from their rooms.
It had become almost like a daily ritual.
A morbid ritual of blood and death.
How quaint.
You almost wept.
Almost.
No mercy for the weak.
It was time to hunt.
~~~~~
It is now Day 4.
With 6 Players alive, it’s 4 Players to Lynch.
We'll make you an offer you can't refuse.
Hosting: Vista Mafia
Hosted: Intrigue Mafia (Mini), Seance #43 (Basic), Conflux Mafia (Normal), Goo Mafia (FTQ), Experiment #26 (Basic)
Ongoing/Completed - 0/41
Town/Mafia/SK/Survivor - 30/6/4/1
NKed/Lynched/Survived - 15/11/15
Are we still in LYLO?
This post by blue strikes my fancy...if TMM was his second suspect, and he flipped town/cop, this could be significant. As such, TMM and Arcadic are my scum suspects.
Games:
Basic 26: Alive : Won
Basic 24: Dead : Lost
Southpark mafia: Dead : draw?
Basic 28: Dead :
Basic 30: Alive :
Annorax's Not-very-Bastard Mod Mafia: Alive
By: Krackshott of Kracked Graphics
IMO, TMM really needs to contribute something worthwhile at this stage of the game, he's still my #1 scum target. Vezo is #2 and Khorney is #3 at this stage. I do plan on re-reading Khorney, but it may be monday at the earliest.
My wife was on MTV with this video.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BUutIZg2EpU
Assuming standard 12 man setup, there are 2 scum left. So yes, still in LYLO. Good point on this early day 3 vote, no-one was willing to wagon and quick lynch over a good amount of time. probably a WIFOM case though.
My wife was on MTV with this video.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BUutIZg2EpU
We have 2 confirmed townies.
4 people in which 2 are scum left.
atlseal could stil be godfather. The amount of power in this town is too great for only one scum RBer.
We had a doc and a cop and a back up.
atlaseal is not the lynch for today.
Everyone says TMM is scum because of one of blue's posts.
He was sure he will die this night so he would have claimed if he found TMM scum.
Look at jobie's list. It's so WIFOM.
I think khorney is scum.
Thanks to DNC at Heroes of the plane studios for this awesome sig and SGT_Chubbz for the awesome avy.
Check out the Shop Thread
- TMM and Arcadic
- TMM and vezok
- Arcadic and vezok
@vezok: After that last post, I'm either sure you're scum or I now completely understand why you're either lynched or vigged in every game. Can you figure out why?
More to come later.
I've been going through the thread looking at all interactions between Jobie, vezok, Arcadic, and TMM. Not all the way through, but here's what I have so far:
[spoilers=Ending at 320 for now]
Jobie:
vezok-
307: Comment on vezok's cantrip or Jobie is scum
Arcadic-
135: Meaningless argument over deriving tone through text
307: Was helping townie, answers Arcadic's question to TMM
TMM-
vezok:
Jobie-
268: Either Jobie or Cantrip is scum
Arcadic-
277: Answers arcadic 276
291: "You wouldn't random kill a potential mis lynch target.
There was some suspicion on OMJ.
They could have killed arcadic or Wataru. Or somebody else like khorney who is percieved town." => Further cements belief that vezok is not scum with Arcadic
TMM-
Arcadic:
Jobie-
275: "Jobie, i would like your reason for forcing a Claim and pushing to l-2. Feel free to quote yourself, but i didn't find a reason."
311: Notes Jobie's answer
vezok-
276: "I am curious as to what information you could get from this thread that he was the doc. The only info i could get was that i felt him as leaning town. I'm more inclined to think they just killed a town. Prove me wrong? Khorney, i also pose you the same question, since you were the inital targeter of OMJ." => Makes me believe both Arcadic and vezok are not scum together
311: Similar feelings to vezok about the kill night before
TMM-
110: Votes for /barning MandersHex on reasons
125: Clarifies position, still pretty much Manders' argument
129: Amaxing deductive skills makes TMM scum and DL town.
134: Now both TMM and DL could be scum
173: Unvotes TMM "I'm still curious about your motives, but not enough to lynch right now."
286: "Random? It seems to me that is a fairly flawed view. I ask, because your not a newbie, why would a random kill benefit the scum more than a targeted one?"
317: Agrees with TMM on 316
TMM:
Jobie-
316: Says didn't see two posts by OMJ cluing power role
vezok-
264: Calls vezoks Sep vote bad
284: "I think the conclusion that those two are scum because they happened to kill a power role is kind of dumb. It appears to just be a random kill."
Arcadic-
126: "It was as simple as me misunderstanding a noob town implosion."
133: Arcadic reading too much into statement
303: Answers "Random?" question from Arcadic. "But the way I see it, on D1 all anyone knew was a rough outline of alignment." <= Compare this to his belief of OMJ and DL day 1[/spoiler]
For me, it's enough to eliminate the vezok/Arcadic scum team. That leaves me with either:
- vezok and TMM
- Arcadic and TMM
So, Vote: TMM. Will continue analysis for rest of thread later.
By the way, Arcadic, sorry about yesterday. I was purposefully trying to get a rise out of you. When people get emotional, they make more mistakes in their posts.
Stuff will come on vezok later.
Quotes in blog.
Jobie:
vezok-
307: Comment on vezok's cantrip or Jobie is scum
329: "What specifically was odd about my response? I'm not a big fan of your short posts that lack causation (in other words they have content but no support)"
359: "@Vezok: What about my responses were scummy? Why are you so sure?"
361: "Huh?"
Arcadic-
135: Meaningless argument over deriving tone through text
307: Was helping townie, answers Arcadic's question to TMM
350: "I don't know of a game on MTGS where the target of a doc protection have known they are being protected.
Also, @Arcadic: Can you explain why that series of quotes are the main reason for your suspicion? I acknowledge the no-unvote was stupid and slightly scummy."
371: Answers Arcadic's questions regarding OMJ/DL posts end of Day 1
TMM-
vezok:
Jobie-
268: Either Jobie or Cantrip is scum
327: Either Jobie or Cantrip is scum, again
354: Votes Jobie after Jobie's response to blue
360: "I am sure cause I say so.
You only respond with fair enough and stuff like that."
Arcadic-
277: Answers arcadic 276
291: "You wouldn't random kill a potential mis lynch target.
There was some suspicion on OMJ.
They could have killed arcadic or Wataru. Or somebody else like khorney who is percieved town." => Further cements belief that vezok is not scum with Arcadic
342: "Blue is awesome. I am not sure about your arcadic read but we will see."
TMM-
Ending post 320:
Arcadic:
Jobie-
275: "Jobie, i would like your reason for forcing a Claim and pushing to l-2. Feel free to quote yourself, but i didn't find a reason."
311: Notes Jobie's answer
345: Votes Jobie + "D1 he tried to appear town while still pushing claims and lynch against DL. That and his failure to unvote at -1, which i didn't pickup on till it was quoted, slip you even further down the scummy trail."
370: Unvotes Jobie for reason in vezok area
vezok-
276: "I am curious as to what information you could get from this thread that he was the doc. The only info i could get was that i felt him as leaning town. I'm more inclined to think they just killed a town. Prove me wrong? Khorney, i also pose you the same question, since you were the inital targeter of OMJ." => Makes me believe both Arcadic and vezok are not scum together
311: Similar feelings to vezok about the kill night before
345: "And yes, it makes zero sense to NK OMJ, however Vezo gave a horrible reasoning why they saw to NK, a power role. IMO this shows knowledge that he was fishing for other reasons beyond a NK to take us off the trail."
370: "However, i am happy with the replies you gave blue over the last 2 pages. I would like to see some hunting from you. I also am unvoting because i do not like Vezo's /barn vote to put you at l-2. It did not end well the last time and i doubt it will this time."
TMM-
110: Votes for /barning MandersHex on reasons
125: Clarifies position, still pretty much Manders' argument
129: Amaxing deductive skills makes TMM scum and DL town.
134: Now both TMM and DL could be scum
173: Unvotes TMM "I'm still curious about your motives, but not enough to lynch right now."
286: "Random? It seems to me that is a fairly flawed view. I ask, because your not a newbie, why would a random kill benefit the scum more than a targeted one?"
317: Agrees with TMM on 316
TMM:
Jobie-
316: Says didn't see two posts by OMJ cluing power role
372: Thinks misunderstanding with Jobie. Content to sit and watch
408: "Huh, I've never actually seen a Jack of All Trades role ever. Is this stuff legit?
I'm inclined to believe his claim, however I don't understand how the role is possible." <= Damning evidence
vezok-
264: Calls vezoks Sep vote bad
284: "I think the conclusion that those two are scum because they happened to kill a power role is kind of dumb. It appears to just be a random kill."
325: Questions vezok's Seppel vote
368: "This is honestly the worst bandwagon jump I have ever seen." (in reference to vezok's vote on Jobie)
438 - "So you want him to find you scummy?
I know enough to know that's just how you play town -- many posts with little to no content and bad votes. It is what it is I suppose."
Arcadic-
126: "It was as simple as me misunderstanding a noob town implosion."
133: Arcadic reading too much into statement
303: Answers "Random?" question from Arcadic. "But the way I see it, on D1 all anyone knew was a rough outline of alignment." <= Compare this to his belief of OMJ and DL day 1
----------------------------------------
In resposne to Sep claiming he was RBed, vezok posts:
"No. It wasn't a good time.
That was dumb." <= Auto-assumes Sep was telling the truth
Then, later:
"In this game apparently you get flavor for being targetted even if you don't have a PR. At least I am hoping for that cause if not that means Sepiriel is a a PR." <= carried on here
---------------------------
I'm actually becoming convinced that the last two scum are vezok and TMM.
Ignore the "Ending post 320:" line. That was a left over from the last update.
vezok-
307: Comment on vezok's cantrip or Jobie is scum
329: "What specifically was odd about my response? I'm not a big fan of your short posts that lack causation (in other words they have content but no support)"
359: "@Vezok: What about my responses were scummy? Why are you so sure?"
361: "Huh?"
533: Willing to shoot vezok
538: "@Vezok: You don't seem angry to me, just blunt and I appreciate it. (no sarcasm, intended)"
Arcadic-
135: Meaningless argument over deriving tone through text
307: Was helping townie, answers Arcadic's question to TMM
350: "I don't know of a game on MTGS where the target of a doc protection have known they are being protected.
Also, @Arcadic: Can you explain why that series of quotes are the main reason for your suspicion? I acknowledge the no-unvote was stupid and slightly scummy."
371: Answers Arcadic's questions regarding OMJ/DL posts end of Day 1
533: Willing to shoot Arcadic
658: Points out Arcadic trying to make blue look scummy
682: "Lynch Arcadic. Lynching me is a loss for the town. (See what I did there?)"
TMM-
533: Willing to shoot TMM
vezok:
Jobie-
268: Either Jobie or Cantrip is scum
327: Either Jobie or Cantrip is scum, again
354: Votes Jobie after Jobie's response to blue
360: "I am sure cause I say so.
You only respond with fair enough and stuff like that."
520: Tells Jobie to use Vig
524: "Jobie kills tonight. If the flavor doesn't matches what he said it's clear he is lying."
534: Jobie, vig someone
673: Lynch Jobie today
695: "Time is up scum. You die."
Arcadic-
277: Answers arcadic 276
291: "You wouldn't random kill a potential mis lynch target.
There was some suspicion on OMJ.
They could have killed arcadic or Wataru. Or somebody else like khorney who is percieved town." => Further cements belief that vezok is not scum with Arcadic
342: "Blue is awesome. I am not sure about your arcadic read but we will see."
511: "If arcadic does and you flip town he will die." (hammering Sep next time he gets on)
660: Wants to lynch Arcadic
TMM-
710: "Everyone says TMM is scum because of one of blue's posts."?
Arcadic:
Jobie-
275: "Jobie, i would like your reason for forcing a Claim and pushing to l-2. Feel free to quote yourself, but i didn't find a reason."
311: Notes Jobie's answer
345: Votes Jobie + "D1 he tried to appear town while still pushing claims and lynch against DL. That and his failure to unvote at -1, which i didn't pickup on till it was quoted, slip you even further down the scummy trail."
370: Unvotes Jobie for reason in vezok area
560: Fine with Jobie vigging self or TMM
677: Jobie is lynch for the day
vezok-
276: "I am curious as to what information you could get from this thread that he was the doc. The only info i could get was that i felt him as leaning town. I'm more inclined to think they just killed a town. Prove me wrong? Khorney, i also pose you the same question, since you were the inital targeter of OMJ." => Makes me believe both Arcadic and vezok are not scum together
311: Similar feelings to vezok about the kill night before
345: "And yes, it makes zero sense to NK OMJ, however Vezo gave a horrible reasoning why they saw to NK, a power role. IMO this shows knowledge that he was fishing for other reasons beyond a NK to take us off the trail."
370: "However, i am happy with the replies you gave blue over the last 2 pages. I would like to see some hunting from you. I also am unvoting because i do not like Vezo's /barn vote to put you at l-2. It did not end well the last time and i doubt it will this time."
707: TMM top scum suspect, vezok 2nd
TMM-
110: Votes for /barning MandersHex on reasons
125: Clarifies position, still pretty much Manders' argument
129: Amaxing deductive skills makes TMM scum and DL town.
134: Now both TMM and DL could be scum
173: Unvotes TMM "I'm still curious about your motives, but not enough to lynch right now."
286: "Random? It seems to me that is a fairly flawed view. I ask, because your not a newbie, why would a random kill benefit the scum more than a targeted one?"
317: Agrees with TMM on 316
560: Fine with Jobie vigging self or TMM
707: TMM top scum suspect, vezok 2nd
TMM:
Jobie-
316: Says didn't see two posts by OMJ cluing power role
372: Thinks misunderstanding with Jobie. Content to sit and watch
408: "Huh, I've never actually seen a Jack of All Trades role ever. Is this stuff legit?
I'm inclined to believe his claim, however I don't understand how the role is possible." <= Damning evidence
442: Likes blue's case on Jobie, wants to wait for Jobie to respond
556: Case for Arcadic Vig
674: "I feel Arcadic is the right lynch for today, but I wouldn't be against a Jobie wagon if it arose."
vezok-
264: Calls vezoks Sep vote bad
284: "I think the conclusion that those two are scum because they happened to kill a power role is kind of dumb. It appears to just be a random kill."
325: Questions vezok's Seppel vote
368: "This is honestly the worst bandwagon jump I have ever seen." (in reference to vezok's vote on Jobie)
438 - "So you want him to find you scummy?
I know enough to know that's just how you play town -- many posts with little to no content and bad votes. It is what it is I suppose."
713: Will case vezok later
Arcadic-
126: "It was as simple as me misunderstanding a noob town implosion."
133: Arcadic reading too much into statement
303: Answers "Random?" question from Arcadic. "But the way I see it, on D1 all anyone knew was a rough outline of alignment." <= Compare this to his belief of OMJ and DL day 1
540: "I would recommend Arcadic for a vig. I don't like the way he's been playing."
562: "If I get vigged, I would still like for you to reply to them." [His points for Arcadic vig]
674: "I feel Arcadic is the right lynch for today, but I wouldn't be against a Jobie wagon if it arose."
713: Mentions his case on Arcadic as contribution
TL;DR: Both Jobie and vezok have pretty much failed to acknowledge that TMM is even playing in this game. Look at Jobie's only interaction with TMM. He offers to shoot him with no mention of TMM before or after that. Vezok just mentions TMM for the first time today in defense of him.
I'm happy with TMM lynch today, vezok goes tomorrow.
THE END
My wife was on MTV with this video.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BUutIZg2EpU
If you're going to barn, at least add something.
@atlseal: I honestly don't understand the format in which you're doing your pbpas. Could you explain? (To make reading easier)
Quotes in blog.
Vez: what do you believe you have contributed to the town?
Games:
Basic 26: Alive : Won
Basic 24: Dead : Lost
Southpark mafia: Dead : draw?
Basic 28: Dead :
Basic 30: Alive :
Annorax's Not-very-Bastard Mod Mafia: Alive
By: Krackshott of Kracked Graphics
Sure, I analyzed interactions between Jobie, Arcadic, vezok, and you. Any time any player made any mention or conversed with any other player, I made a note. Top level (bolded) are the origin, italicized are the destination. So for instance,
Jobie:
TMM-
150: Said blah
Would mean, Jobie said blah to TMM in post 150.
Again, both Jobie and vezok have all but ignored your existence in this game. Scum often talk/debate with/about each other because they already know each other are scum. It seems as if your scum partners unwillingly outed you by ignoring you.
Missing the all-important word.
Games:
Basic 26: Alive : Won
Basic 24: Dead : Lost
Southpark mafia: Dead : draw?
Basic 28: Dead :
Basic 30: Alive :
Annorax's Not-very-Bastard Mod Mafia: Alive
By: Krackshott of Kracked Graphics
Vezok, would you be willing to vote for TMM?
Games:
Basic 26: Alive : Won
Basic 24: Dead : Lost
Southpark mafia: Dead : draw?
Basic 28: Dead :
Basic 30: Alive :
Annorax's Not-very-Bastard Mod Mafia: Alive
By: Krackshott of Kracked Graphics
Games:
Basic 26: Alive : Won
Basic 24: Dead : Lost
Southpark mafia: Dead : draw?
Basic 28: Dead :
Basic 30: Alive :
Annorax's Not-very-Bastard Mod Mafia: Alive
By: Krackshott of Kracked Graphics
Games:
Basic 26: Alive : Won
Basic 24: Dead : Lost
Southpark mafia: Dead : draw?
Basic 28: Dead :
Basic 30: Alive :
Annorax's Not-very-Bastard Mod Mafia: Alive
By: Krackshott of Kracked Graphics
The Muffin Man (4) - atlseal, Arcadic, Powerrox93, khorney06
With 6 Players alive, it’s 4 Players to Lynch.
As of this post, a Lynch has occurred.
~~~~~
It was simple really.
Everything was narrowed down to a single choice.
Judging from the way the wind blew, you had already moved away.
A safe distance.
And from where you stood, you looked intently at The Muffin Man.
He crouched down unmoving.
His gaze was lifeless as the verdict was given.
But he was smiling.
An empty smile.
Devoid of feelings.
Understandably, no one moved closer.
Tick.
The Muffin Man raised his hands.
Everyone tensed.
But he sat motionless.
He only held up his hands to the lights above.
And he stared at them.
Silent.
Tentatively, you raised one of your hands up as well.
And you stared at it.
You didn’t understand.
Framed by the lights, there was a corona of red tingeing the edges of your hand.
And then you did understand.
The Muffin Man then covered his head with both arms and rested them above his knees.
I’m sorry, he whispered.
It was so soft you could barely hear it.
And then he wept.
His body heaved and shook.
You closed your eyes and turned around, heading for your room.
Behind you, you heard the distinct sound of pop.
The sound of which would plague your nightmares from now on.
Even as you strode forward, a stream of information filtered into your brain.
The Muffin Man, Mafia Vanilla has been lynched.
So be it.
The metallic doors slid open.
And then there were five.
The curtains were coming down fast.
Tick.
~~~~~
It is now Night 4.
Night 4 will last for a maximum of 72 hours. Please submit your action choices by PM before then. No posting in the game thread during the Night phase.
We'll make you an offer you can't refuse.
Hosting: Vista Mafia
Hosted: Intrigue Mafia (Mini), Seance #43 (Basic), Conflux Mafia (Normal), Goo Mafia (FTQ), Experiment #26 (Basic)
Ongoing/Completed - 0/41
Town/Mafia/SK/Survivor - 30/6/4/1
NKed/Lynched/Survived - 15/11/15
GO SCUM!!!
Quotes in blog.
You felt tired.
You couldn’t sleep.
It was a restless night.
Every second passed was a second closer to resolution.
Time was running out.
You were feeling the weight of the world on your shoulders.
The metallic door slid open.
You blinked.
It was day already?
You paused.
You hesitated.
Steeling yourself, you got up and moved through the doorway.
It was time for resolution.
For better or worse, this living nightmare might finally come to an end.
As you stepped into the chamber, a stream of information filtered into your brain.
Powerrox93, Town Backup has been killed.
And then there were four.
Only four doors slid open.
Only four people walked to the center of the chamber.
Only four players left for a discussion.
Checkmate was nearing.
But for which side?
~~~~~
It is now Day 5.
With 4 Players alive, it’s 3 Players to Lynch.
We'll make you an offer you can't refuse.
Hosting: Vista Mafia
Hosted: Intrigue Mafia (Mini), Seance #43 (Basic), Conflux Mafia (Normal), Goo Mafia (FTQ), Experiment #26 (Basic)
Ongoing/Completed - 0/41
Town/Mafia/SK/Survivor - 30/6/4/1
NKed/Lynched/Survived - 15/11/15
Let's end this already. Unless vezok or khorney can provide a very good reason for me to switch my vote to Arcadic, vezok is where my vote is going to stay.
If you needed any proof Khorney that Vezo is scum here's the proof. Altseal was confirmed town by blue who was confirmed town at this time.
Vote: Vezok
My wife was on MTV with this video.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BUutIZg2EpU
Games:
Basic 26: Alive : Won
Basic 24: Dead : Lost
Southpark mafia: Dead : draw?
Basic 28: Dead :
Basic 30: Alive :
Annorax's Not-very-Bastard Mod Mafia: Alive
By: Krackshott of Kracked Graphics